Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 17 · 25 April 1902
3printed page
scan 3 of 16

No. 17 — "Die Welt" — Page 3

(continued from page 2)

…rabbis have soon lost all control over the machine. If the first or territorial period of Judaism has been described as that with Law and Land, and the second or Ghetto period as that with Law but without Land, then the third or American period must be called that without Law and Land. A knowledge of Hebrew is there the last thing demanded of a rabbi. I will not assert that in giving up Dr. Schechter to America the Old World restores the balance of the New, for the country which has begun the "Jewish Encyclopaedia" is on the way to bringing itself into balance. Nor must it be forgotten that it was Christian institutions, and not Jewish, which have hitherto maintained Dr. Schechter in our midst, and American Jewry gives us a lesson in how mind and learning are to be prized as the noblest possession of a community.

As an ardent adherent of Dr. Schechter's ideas, I find in him nowhere that dogmatism of which I have read in American newspapers, for the reason that he stands for Rabbinic Judaism, whereas the Rabbis of the Talmud were not Orthodox but progressive reformers. Indeed a reaction is at present on the way in America, to which Dr. Schechter is to give form and direction: the old families who sold their Sabbath lamps as Ghetto grotesques and are now buying them back as aesthetic antiques may be brought by Dr. Schechter to light them once more!

Three years ago, when I was myself in the United States, I had occasion to express my apprehension — and the thought has been misunderstood then and ever since, again and again — that American Judaism in its violent reaction would return to the old ossified Orthodoxy — tempered by oysters. It was just in those days that the rumour of Dr. Schechter's coming was first heard, and an enthusiastic American girl asked me: "Shall we have to keep everything when Dr. Schechter comes?" So readily do belief in miracles and myths shoot up even in our own day. It hardly needs saying that the only wonders Dr. Schechter means to work are those of stimulus and inspiration, and that the effect of his coming is to be not immediate but cumulative. No Mazzoth will fall from heaven upon heterodox households. What Dr. Schechter brings to America is his traditional knowledge, his incomparable learning, his Jewish feeling, joined with the insight that the development of Judaism must go its own ways. For his enlightenment he will go to the Synagogue, to the fountain-head, not to those wells which have sprung from it but give back the holy water with another after-taste.

Dr. Schechter has always recognised that Judaism has its own character and tone, and that it is ridiculous to proclaim that Judaism has a mission and then to grope about for what sort of mission it may be.

I do not believe that Dr. Schechter will abolish oysters. It is hard to discern the principle on which the American rabbis proceed and decide, unless it be that it is better to eat oysters openly than to open them in secret, as here. Assuredly they know that in so doing they are setting aside the Mosaic precepts; if only they had remained true to their spirit! Had they — while permitting oysters — yet forbidden crabs and lobsters, because these are boiled alive, they would have developed Judaism further in harmony with its humanitarian views. Or had they forbidden uninspected water or uninspected milk — the most fertile breeding-grounds of microbes — or made vaccination a Mizwah, they would have developed Judaism further on its hygienic side. A conscious adaptation of modern views would produce a higher Judaism than that military Mosaism of the Egyptian slaves. Autocratic laws produce autocratic soldiers and nothing else, and the proof of it is the ease with which the soldier throws off the yoke the moment he begins to doubt the authority of the command. Discipline may be a military virtue, but self-discipline is a spiritual virtue, and only such a Judaism can celebrate a Passover of freedom.

Besides this illogical chaos which Doctor Schechter will find in America, he will also meet an extraordinarily logical and consistent tendency: a powerful school which abhors all hopes of a restoration of the Holy Land and expunges every expression of that hope from the liturgy. "Washington is our Zion!" is the new cry, and its honest expression commands my respect just as does the historic refusal of the Orthodox community of Amsterdam to accept Dutch rights of citizenship.

A man cannot serve two masters, and both proceedings are honest attempts to escape the dilemma bequeathed to posterity by the Rabbis when, after the fall of Jerusalem, they linked the second or landless period of Judaism with the modes of thought and expression of the first. I do not know whether Dr. Schechter contemplates leading back the only logical American development to the chaos which reigns in that country; I rather hope that if he sets the pendulum swinging, it will be towards the only logical alternative, towards Zionism; all the more since Dr. Schechter was born in that cruel land (Roumania) which casts its shadow over our banquet, and gives us a lesson well worth taking to heart of how necessary is a land of refuge for our persecuted and homeless brethren. Murderers had more cities of refuge in little Palestine than the Roumanian Jews find to-day in the whole world.

Dr. Schechter has himself thus defined the office of a Guide of the Perplexed in his masterly "Studies in Judaism": The true authorities are those who, drawing their inspiration from the past, know how to bring us into harmony with the present and to prepare us for the future. Now that he is called to shape that future actively through his Seminary, he must take this heavy task upon himself too; heavier through the fact that Dr. Schechter regards Judaism as a missionary religion, able through its ideas to shape those of the world. But Judaism will no longer be a solitary lighthouse in the midst of a dark sea. It is not, as perhaps in Pharaoh's time, the only sentinel against idolatry and immorality. Other