Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 14
(continued from page 3)
…standings, and we wish unequivocally to dissociate ourselves from them, and to express our deep regret and our sincere apology for their publication. It is proper to add that, although this apology was sent to Mr. H. R. Lewis for examination on the part of his clients, it must be regarded as our own spontaneous act, and we do not represent it as having been settled by him before publication. We consider it our duty towards our readers and ourselves, as towards the Jewish Colonial Trust, to make this correction and apology.
"Why We Have No Geniuses."
By Dr. Adolf Friedemann (Wiesbaden).
The writer of these lines recently had a lengthy Zionist debate with Mr. X., who was formerly a famous actor. As such he played Shylock and Nathan the Wise with equal impartiality, and gradually, through his society and his profession, he has arrived at a standpoint which, as he believes, enables him to see things objectively. And so he says that the Zionist movement is in itself, no doubt, a fine conception — not because it contradicts a misunderstood cosmopolitanism, but because the final goal of all striving must be the perfect man. The Jewish race, however, is the people of gifted mediocrities; mixed with Germandom it yields brilliant "breeding results," but by itself it has never, save Spinoza, brought forth a genius.
If, then, we are unable to achieve the highest, we have likewise no particular right to exist.
This line of argument, which in similar form is favoured precisely by men of high intellectual standing and great influence, has at first sight much that is plausible. In reality it is altogether mistaken, even from the standpoint of the aristocrat of the intellect who despises the "many-too-many," or who, like Sohm, would exterminate the "non-people." Moreover, it contains an inner contradiction: for mediocrities can never be employed to fructify a race, but always only outstanding individualities. Every breeder of horses or dogs knows that. If, therefore, Judaism consisted of talented mediocrities, a mixture with Germandom would be most inexpedient. It would be desirable only if we achieved the highest — and that is precisely what the other side disputes. But the argument is false also because it proceeds from a false premise. It is conceded that we produce relatively many talents and comparatively few geniuses. But does that actually prove that we are less capable of it than other peoples? In the first place, geniuses in the highest sense of the word, the men who show the world new paths, are altogether very rare — too rare for statistics to be made of them. How few men have issued from the Slavonic race to whom one can concede the right to bear the title of genius? And have the 150 millions of Slavs on that account lost their national right to exist? Certainly not. The mere observation of the steadily increasing number of intellectual great men in Russia makes the conclusion appear justified that, in more advanced stages of culture, the East will bestow upon us wonderful blossoms of the mind. Already to-day it has given us a Tolstoi. A hundred years ago, however, it was still a maxim with Goethe: the Russians have no geniuses. So geniuses do, after all, come with the growing strength of a people in the intellectual sphere. Only when the general level of education has reached a certain limit can intellectual great men be born, for before that they find no field for their activity, no possibility for the full unfolding of their powers. And a second thing must also be present to open the way for genius: that is, a sphere of action not too narrowly measured.
It is just as improbable that a mighty poet, artist or thinker should be born to-day in the United States — a man of truly towering importance, capable of opening new paths — as that he should arise in Servia or Bulgaria. If in the latter countries there is lacking the level of culture that makes fruitful creation possible, in the United States, with their medley of peoples, the possibility is lost because the milieu is not uniform and is without tradition, because the sense of belonging together, founded solely on the idea of the State, is unable to call forth self-contained thought, feeling rooted in the soil, and unity of personality — those qualities which, as it seems, are indispensable to the nature of genius. Genius thinks intuitively, not deductively. But only those men can think intuitively in whom the life of feeling pulses strongly, who possess, moreover, a strong self-confidence that permits them rapid conclusions, and, lastly, only men of vigorous will. Just as it is impossible that genius should ever bloom in obscurity, precisely because the will, the striving towards the deed, is a part of itself, so is the presence of strong feeling a precondition. For the cool-thinking man will shrink from the impulsive conclusion of genius, because in it sober reason does not seem to come sufficiently into its rights. But how is a clear and strong life of feeling, directed towards outward things, to arise when outward circumstances are of a heterogeneous nature? Is the poet of genius to be born in a circle without a common language? Is he in New York to write his poetry in English, Irish, German or Italian? He will never possess the deep feeling for the beauty of a single mother tongue, since he has, after all, two or three mother tongues; and the will to the deed will be lacking, the will to create in one of those languages.
Bismarck is a very characteristic example of what makes the man of genius. His ruthless will, his unbridled love of action, lead him in his youth to commit all manner of follies which in average men would have to meet with far severer judgment. Throughout his whole life he remains the destroyer of his enemies; he compromises seldom, almost never; he is at times ruthless to the point of brutality. Side by side with this he is often childishly tender, religious, of the most delicate feeling. In his rage over an unfavourable piece of news he smashes a whole set of plates, and the next moment he is like a gentle lamb because his wife speaks a kind word to him.
And lastly, he remains a Junker his whole life long. This too — bizarre as it sounds at first — was a necessary precondition for his magnificent achievement. For him the word Junker signifies the patriarchally sound nobleman of the distinguished old style, who sits defiantly upon his own soil, is incapable of becoming a courtier, and is a faithful liegeman to the King. "I will bring the name of Junker to honour," Bismarck once said, and he kept his word. He carried the circle of thought in which he had grown up over with him into the life of the diplomat and the statesman — he had to take it with him, because it made him a unified, inwardly rounded man. Even when he occasionally governed liberally or proceeded against his fellow-nobles, he never lost his firm hold. He was rooted, in fact, with every fibre of being