Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 10 · 7 March 1902
5printed page
scan 5 of 16

No. 10 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 5

Providence, Palestine and the Rothschilds.

By Israel Zangwill.*)

When, after the suppression of the Rebellion of 1745 in favour of the Stuarts, the benevolent Government of the House of Hanover, which had come to the English throne (and which, like nearly everything in history, had been very largely financed by the Jews), wished to grant naturalisation to these loyal guests, the Minister Pelham was reproached with wishing to set himself against the hand of Providence. Providence — so it was held — willed that the Jews should remain without a fatherland until they should be restored to their own fatherland. Now that a mighty Zionist movement exists throughout the whole world and strives to attain this very fatherland of their own, the Zionists are now reproached with wishing to force the hand of Providence. It would be a far truer conception of contemporary history, adopting the dogmatic phraseology of these pseudo-theologians, to say that Providence is forcing the hand of the Zionists. For in truth, precisely in recent times, widely separated threads of history have woven themselves together into a striking picture.

Let us examine in simple outline the factors of the eternal wandering of the Jews in their relation to the great hope which has made this wandering bearable. These factors are: the situation of the Jewish people, of Palestine, and of the ruler of Palestine.

The situation of the Jews is, contrary to superficial appearance, worse at present than it was centuries ago. For their true emancipation, where it has really been carried through, has merely prepared their dissolution. It is impossible for the small minority, which no longer has the moats of the ghetto walls, to escape total absorption by the great waves of Western life which surge upon it. The mere impossibility, arising from the demands of industry, of keeping two Sabbaths in the week is destroying the Jewish Sabbath, the true corner-stone of the Jewish religion, whereas all assaults upon this ancient sanctuary have always failed miserably.

This destructive emancipation, however, touches only a minority of the Jews. More than half of the eleven million Jews live in Russia, and the greater part of them are penned together in the border districts, and are hard pressed and harried by the levelling policy through which Holy Russia is to be transformed into a religious unity.

In Roumania a quarter of a million Jews are being driven out by legislation, in merciless disregard of the Treaty of Berlin. Only the million Jews in America are free, if not socially equal. The slum quarters of the great cities of the world have reached a point of saturation as regards their capacity to absorb the stream of immigration of destitute Russian and Roumanian Jews. London itself is beginning, through the "British Brothers' League" and a Parliamentary inquiry, to protest against their continual influx. Germany, Austria and Hungary have their antisemitic parties, and France is no longer the land in whose


*) Our untiring friend Zangwill published the above article in the number of the English periodical "The Speaker" of the 22nd February of this year, and it will assuredly be of great interest to the readers of the "Welt".

capital it would be the pleasure of a Rothschild to remain as ambassador.

Looking round about us, we observe to our astonishment that of all the countries inhabited by any considerable Jewish population, only one single one is free from antisemitism, a single one in which the Jewish inhabitants live in absolute peace with their neighbours — and that is the Turkish Empire.

In European and Asiatic Turkey live no fewer than 450,000 Jews. Perhaps they get on so well with the Mohammedans because their religious usages are rather closely akin. Islam, after all, is nothing other than Israel translated into Arabic. But it may also be that more religious toleration prevails in the Turkish Empire than is generally known in the rest of Europe — especially since the unhappy Armenian episode. Did not Greek subjects of the Sultan — Christian students of the University of Geneva — declare not long ago in all due form that complete religious toleration prevails in the Ottoman Empire, that all religious observances are freely permitted, and that in the eyes of the Government no distinction exists between the Mohammedan and the non-Mohammedan population? And — if we look backward — do we not find that the darkest, most persecuting times of Christendom coincide with the brightest periods of Mohammedan culture and tolerance?

But how stands it with that particular part of the Turkish Empire upon which the eyes of the Jewish people have been fixed for eighteen hundred years? Palestine might have been densely peopled by the Turks, or by Arabs or Europeans; it might have been exploited by the industrial forces of modern civilisation; or it might have fallen into the hands of France or Germany or Russia, each of which has sought to establish a sphere of influence there. But no — it has remained to this moment the least inhabited, the most forgotten and the most ruined of Turkish territories, notwithstanding its situation in the very centre of the old world, and its relations to the Mediterranean, to the Suez Canal, to Egypt and to the Persian Gulf, which assure it a commercial and strategic future of high importance.

The land is by no means past flowing once more with milk and honey. If taken in hand from lofty points of view — like Egypt — its reawakening, like that of Egypt, will amply repay the capital put into it. The streams of Jewish immigration — elsewhere so unwelcome — would here find their natural channel and bring the whole land to fruitfulness and bloom.

For these Jewish refugees are no beggars; most of them are artisans and some are husbandmen. The labour so necessary in new colonies would thus be supplied by the centripetal force of persecution on the one side and the centrifugal force of the attraction of the Holy Land on the other. The Zionist societies which the Jewish emigrants hasten to found, scarcely have they set foot ashore in Cape Breton or South Africa, prove how gladly these artisans would have gone straight to Zion. Zion is indeed nearer to the Russian border provinces, and the passage from Odessa across the Black Sea costs only 30 shillings.