No. 6 — "Die Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
…as well as died for it. In its place I substitute the charge of Philistinism.
We must not, like journalists, judge the process of history by days, months or years. "The mills of God grind slowly"; the leaven of sentiment works steadily, and the victory of power is often only the victory of another sentiment. For sentiments must naturally transform themselves of their own accord into material forms; they must not remain watery aspirations.
When in the year 1848 General Radetzky had taken Milan and crushed the rising of several Italian states against Austria, an Austrian artist met an Italian artist who had been his schoolfellow. "Well, you have been torn to shreds!" he said. "That is a fact," the Italian answered calmly, "but we have an idea." That idea was the unity and independence of this crushed and riven Italy, and thirteen years later Victor Emmanuel was proclaimed King of "United Italy" by the first Italian Parliament.
Only wait, ladies and gentlemen, until our idea is thirteen years old, and you will see what a splendid Bar-Mitzvah we shall have!
When, in the darkest days of the Boer War, I was conversing with an English lady, I happened to tell her of a man who had said to me that everywhere people were now trying to trample England down, since she is now hard pressed. "Trample down!" cried the Englishwoman in a burst of feeling. "England is not down, and what is more, England's sons and daughters cannot possibly be brought to contemplate the possibility that their country should lie on the ground." I then spoke of another subject, but I thought that this was surely the right spirit, the spirit that prevents England from ever being trampled down by strangers, since her sons and daughters would never admit the idea that their homeland lies on the ground. Alas! In our case it is just the opposite. Our people cannot contemplate the possibility that it is able to raise itself up, and it is this spirit that presses it to the ground.
Even when they are rich, their money is used to strengthen every other nation but their own. And what is the reward?
A few days before the mass meeting against immigration in the People's Palace, the newspapers let it out that the anonymous donor of £200,000 to the King for British hospitals was a Jewish immigrant named Sir Ernest Cassel. Did this fact prevent the anti-Semitic meeting? Had it any effect whatever upon the demagogues of that platform? Not one jot. Let us suppose that, since the movement against alien immigration began among us, 100,000 Jews have immigrated — the last census and exact counts by N. S. Josephs and L. J. Greenberg have shown that there are fewer — then Sir Ernest Cassel's gift to Christendom amounts to two pounds for every immigrant Jew. I am certain the money would have been far better employed had it been given to Zionism; for if we really do the Christians in the East End an injury, as they allege, what a boon to them would our Zionist movement then be, which aims at keeping the poor Jews away from this country and bringing them to Palestine. We Zionists are the only ones who foresaw this anti-Semitic agitation and who tried to take a stand against it even before it appeared. The other Jews live only from hand to mouth and build upon sand. They form a Holland below the level of the sea, and do not take the trouble to keep the dykes in order. Zionism would not be dismayed at the British Brothers League⁵) if only our brethren would act like Britons, and if, instead of contenting themselves with the exclusion of the immigrant Jews, they would kindly help us to find another home for them.
As an Englishman I hold their policy to be extraordinarily petty, short-sighted, and dishonourable to the great tradition of English liberty, that liberty for which we are fighting across the water. To fight for the rights of the Uitlanders in the Transvaal and to restrict the rights of the Uitlanders at home is a deplorable contradiction. Nevertheless I can perfectly understand the excitement in East London. For our Jewish statistics, which merely show how many thousands of Jews immigrate yearly, give no exact picture so long as they leave out of account the circumstance that more than half of these thousands of Jews settle upon the same narrow area. But wherever the shoe pinches and is tight, there one feels the pain, however large and wide the shoe may otherwise be. It is beside the mark to point, as Mr. S. Joseph does, to the overcrowding of St. Pancras and Camberwell⁶). The question at issue is not one of heavy overcrowding but of unequal distribution.
The battle-cry against the Jews, however, is only another form of that protectionist policy which our leading statesmen have always disowned; it is the same cry that went up when human labour was superseded by machine labour. It is the natural outcry of those who are displaced; and just as the Luddites⁷) in their day broke the machines, so our British Brothers will probably one day wreck the Jewish quarters. That would seem terrible to our English Jews, but on the Continent it is an episode to which people have long since grown accustomed. Of this our English Jews have no conception, since they have not joined the Jewish Brotherhood League and were but sparsely represented at Basle.
The reports of this great Congress give only a faint echo of those memorable days, of those sleepless nights. The work done on the platform was scarcely a tenth part of what was really accomplished. Wherever anyone turned his steps in that many-roomed Casino, he came upon committee meetings. I must confess that I know but little of what went on. My own share was as small as possible, much smaller than that of our Chairman, who was elected Vice-President, which is equivalent to "Mr. Speaker"⁸) in our Parliament. My work was confined solely to a speech in which I criticised the trustees of the Hirsch Foundation for the manner in which a great world concern has been made into a parish-pump affair, and in which the millions destined for Israel's salvation are frittered away for want of any concentration.
This speech of mine called forth a somewhat superfluous speech from my friend Dr. Gaster at the Anglo Jewish Association, in which he dissociated himself from my feelings and sentiments. But, as the Chairman, Mr. Claude Montefiore, already said, no one supposed that I was speaking in any name other than my own. Dr. Gaster defends the Jewish Colonization Association, or, to use the better-known abbreviation, the "Ica," on three points: 1. that the "Ica" is but little responsible for the administration of the Palestinian colonies, since these have been directed by a special Palestinian Committee, and that the discourtesy of this Committee towards the international deputation last year is only unjustly laid at the door of the "Ica"; 2. that the "Ica"