Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 28 · 12 July 1901
6printed page
scan 6 of 16

Page 6 — "Die Welt" — No. 28

(continued from page 5)

…had to employ very radical means in order to bring about a complete restoration to health of these conditions.

In the first rank, the abolition of serfdom, the granting of greater liberties to the peasants, and the restriction of the arbitrary power of the landowners would have proved unavoidably necessary. But this the rulers of that day neither could nor would do, since they were themselves owners of estates and of slaves, and their own interests were therefore involved. It was necessary, accordingly, to find another "cause," one lying outside these social anomalies, and to which the whole blame might be ascribed. Already at the giving of the commission mentioned above, the Minister Derzawin received a hint from above as to where he was to look for the "cause." Nothing was easier for the Minister than to follow this hint. He now had no further need to institute serious and thorough investigations; the cause of all causes had been found: the Jews, who exploit the population, who corrupt the clergy and the officialdom, etc., etc. Thus, for example, Derzawin establishes the wretched condition of the population in White Russia, and assigns various causes for this dismal state — as, for instance, that the Poles are indolent, neglect their fields, are averse to industry, and are idlers and drunkards, and that for nine years in succession there had been a failure of the crops. At the same time, however, he adds that of all the causes of the misery "the great number of the Jews in these governments is the chief one." "And this tendency," Herr Gessen observes upon this, "to hold the Jews to be the cause of all the imperfections in the economic and intellectual-moral life of the native people, and to call them in to explain every misfortune — this tendency was received with approval both by the local authorities and in St. Petersburg." Now the carrying through of radical reforms in the State could once more be postponed, and instead of that men need only busily drive the Jews out of the villages and out of certain towns and localities. But once it was accepted as a fact that the Jews were the fundamental evil, then logically the question had also to be asked why the Jews were in fact such exploiters, why they pursued none but harmful occupations. Had men been willing to pursue the matter further in a logical fashion and to investigate thoroughly the conditions of Jewish life, they must inevitably have come to the conclusion that the Jews persisted in their occupations because no possibility was given them of ordering their life otherwise. They had to be hucksters because they were not permitted to be tillers of the soil, because they were restricted in their rights of residence and in their other rights. In a word, men must needs have arrived at the necessity of a reformation of the economic conditions of Jewish life; and this the statesmen of that day likewise carefully evaded. They therefore made matters comfortable for themselves by explaining the moral and intellectual degradation of the Kehilla Jews by their fanaticism, by "the pernicious doctrines of the Talmud." Most Jews are hucksters, not because they can be nothing else, but because, following the teaching of the Talmud, they "must shun heavy labour and seek only easy gains by means of cunning and fraud." By what means, then, is this evil to be combated? Not by rational economic measures, but by the "enlightenment" of the Jews through compulsory measures and through still greater restrictions upon the rights of the unenlightened. This circumstance was, according to Herr Geesen, the reason why the Government was so willingly and so unconcernedly disposed to carry "enlightenment" into the Jewish masses, while towards the peasants it bore itself by no means so friendly to enlightenment. "The enlightened serf peasants" — says Herr Gessen — "might protest against serfdom, that corner-stone of the social order of the day; but in the case of the 'enlightened' Jews this danger did not exist."

We see, then, that the real causes of the so lively interest of the Russian Governments in the enlightenment of the Jews were not nationalistic currents alone, as Dubnow supposes (national and religious motives were, to be sure, also decisive, as Orschansky proves; but we cannot here enter more closely upon the discussion of all these subsidiary circumstances) — the chief causes of this interest were purely economic and political. In the memorandum of the year 1840 also, from which Herr Dubnow draws his conclusions, pointing to the utterances contained in it concerning the separation of the Jews "from the general civil life," from the whole of the rest of the population — in this memorandum too there is, as we have already seen, no talk of "Russian-national" or "Jewish-national" Jews, but of "useful and useless" Jews, of such as "have productive occupations, or else perform no productive labour," who "exploit or do not exploit the native population." The higher or lower cultural standing of the Jews was in all this no more than a pretext. The establishment of these motives of the Russian Government of that day in its striving to raise the cultural condition of the Jews seems to us of importance because in later times also we meet with these motives in the Government ordinances concerning the Jews.

"Under the reign of Alexander II. also," remarks Herr Margulies in his article "Ilja Grigorowitsch Orschansky" (monthly numbers of the "Woskhod," January 1901), "almost all the laws touching the extension of Jewish rights are built upon the same principle of drawing profit from the Jewish people." "Let us add," he further observes, "the law of the 3rd of May 1882, which lies heavy upon the Jews, in whose legislative motives the exploitation of the native population is openly pointed to." Wherever in history men have wished to conceal the real causes of an abuse, they have done it in this manner: by making the Jews the scapegoat.

In the next article we shall come, as we have already mentioned, to an epoch gratifying in the history of the Russian Jews, which, however, did not last long. That was the time of the sixties, which will soon lead us to the grey present.

(To be continued.)

An "Oculist" in Jerusalem.

It is well known that the number of persons suffering from diseases of the eye in Palestine, and in Jerusalem in particular, is very great. The so-called "Egyptian ophthalmia," the trachoma, rages there to a degree that inspires horror. This frightful pestilence has claimed many victims in Jerusalem this year especially, since through the failure of the latter rain a general want of water has set in, and the uncleanliness thereby occasioned furthers the spread of the contagion. It is characteristic of conditions in Jerusalem that the number of oculists, in proportion to the number of the sick, is positively ludicrous in its smallness.

Properly speaking, there are but two oculists in Jerusalem: Dr. Kent, appointed by the English Missionary Society, and a certain Dr. L. Rothstein, whom three years ago a Jewish society named פוקח עורים ("Opener of the Eyes of the Blind") sent for from Alexandria, but already after the lapse of a