Page 8. — “Die Welt” — No. 11.
(continued from page 7)
…Zionism has struck here. There is still wanting the outcome of the outward documentation of Zionism, the result of this year's shekel collection, whereby to institute a comparison with the first and second Congress years; I expressly do not name the third Congress year, because the shekel collections, undertaken only at the last hour, did not embrace even the half of the Zionists then to be found in Berlin and are therefore not decisive for comparisons. More, however, than in the formal number of the Zionists, the strength of our movement in Berlin will be recognisable in the inner life of the societies and in the further development of the institutions. There it will first appear whether this or that new creation is capable of life, whether many a beginning will also be capable of being translated into deed.
Certain, however, is the fact that the Zionists here have in the current winter unfolded an eminent activity, carried on a far-reaching agitation and further trained the forces at hand. The ways which the several societies have entered upon were of very various kinds, differing in forms and tendencies, but in all the groups work was done in a measure deserving of recognition. Even where a criticism of the individual achievements would lower the value of many an undertaking, it would yet for the most part have to concede the presence of an intense zeal. Not unessential in this connection is the circumstance that the Zionists here were during the past winter, in all their societies, almost exclusively thrown upon such fellow Zionists as were locally present (Germans, or persons resident here).
Of a certain moment for the energy of the Zionists was the fusion, already effected last summer, of the two local groups, which had formerly squandered no inconsiderable part of their strength in personal bickerings. The differences among the Zionists in their views and tendencies, which undoubtedly exist, had found scarcely any corresponding expression in this manner of grouping, so that the separation of these local groups seemed of late to be justified by nothing. The material differences have naturally not vanished and will certainly emerge yet more strongly in the conflict of ideas, the more so since the Fourth Zionist Congress has itself given occasion thereto by the raising of various problems. No wonder, therefore, that even now Zionism is propagated here in very various fashion: everyone sees in Zionism precisely the expression of his own view of the world. More even than the formal union of the two Zionist local groups, the activity — not always making itself known in noisy meetings, but no less intense — of a number of persons in the various societies and circles has influenced and furthered Zionist life and has been able to win for our movement the most manifold connections.
Of the questions which have particularly occupied Zionist circles there are to be mentioned, besides the Congress proceedings, which were sharply criticised, the discussions upon Zionism itself (with special regard to Socialism), upon the situation of the Jewish labourers in Palestine, upon phenomena of the neo-Hebrew literature (Achad-Haam, Berdyczewski) and much else, above all three matters: the Roumanian Jewish distress, the projected German Jewish Day, and the behaviour of the delegates of the Jewish Labour League at the Paris Socialist Congress. These three themes formed not only the content of separate lectures, but gave also to most of the other debates a definite direction, enlivened the at times academic disquisitions, and lent to the speeches fire and edge, sadness and strength. At one moment they were echoes of the Congresses, from Nordau, whose sombre pictures of the general mood were confirmed by new facts; at another it was a mighty indignation at the shameful silence of the representatives of the “Jewish” Labour League; at another a call to the organisation of the German Jews for a worthy struggle.
The debate upon the German Jewish Day has indeed diverted the Berlin Zionists all too much from their proper striving, but it has attained one purpose. It has shown in the clearest manner the bankruptcy of Jewish assimilation in Germany. Assimilated Jewry, whose task it was to stand up with all energy for the equality of rights already officially disavowed, was able to be “indignant” only behind closed doors, and displayed an incredible servility and timorousness. Thus the loud struggle of the Zionists was, especially at the beginning, a refreshment, and as a passing phenomenon a deed. Very serious, however, would it be for the further development of our idea in Germany if the Zionists should begin to take part in such measure in struggles for the equality of rights, although they are conscious that from that quarter they have not their salvation to expect. It was only a question of establishing that the Zionists do not think of surrendering their rights, just as they have to fulfil their duties towards the land in which they dwell, and have to fulfil them not only upon legal, formal grounds, but far more upon natural, ethical motives. Further, it was a question of branding the egoistic indifferentism of the German Jews with regard to their own future, of scaring away the petty shopkeeper spirit and of spurring them on to a general organisation; it meant carrying dignity and self-consciousness into a struggle hitherto conducted almost always without dignity. Most important of all, however, was it to point again and again to the consequences of such a Jewish Day, which must assuredly lead to enlightenment concerning their own situation, their own nature, the future, and therefore indirectly to Zionism. But the new path which the Zionists entered upon led very often, and latterly in particular, to dangerous derailments, and many a speech which was delivered by Zionists on behalf of the Jewish Day has inwardly weakened Zionism; individual Zionists fell out of the key and strayed into the domain of the so-called “Abwehr” sans phrase. If, then, the Jewish-Day movement brought before the public by the Zionists has assuredly been a noteworthy display of strength, on the other hand the utmost caution is in place, that the Zionist standpoint be not wholly displaced.
A conflict of opinion no less violent than the Jewish-Day debates was called forth by the discussions upon the behaviour of the representatives of the Jewish Labour League at the Paris Socialist Congress. In German-Zionist meetings too, mention was several times made, with bitter scorn and vehement censure, of the fact that these representatives of “Jewish” masses kept the most thorough silence when the said Congress, in its manifestation of sympathy for the oppressed nations, left precisely the most persecuted people, the Jewish, unmentioned. One particular circle, however, namely the Russo-Jewish body of students in Berne, amounting to several hundreds, was thrown by this affair into a positively feverish agitation. The Russian Zionists beheld in this fact so extraordinary a servitude that they sought at least to give expression to their indignation, and the Zionist society of Russian students “Kadimah” wished to pass a resolution in this sense. Thereupon there were several, so to speak historic, students' meetings, in which strong passions