Page 2. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 9.
(continued from page 1)
…within the lands of their present sojourn, and therefore of Galicia also. The premises of the undertaking are accordingly false. That does not hinder us from receiving the undertaking itself in friendly fashion, if only because it may fill us with satisfaction and with good hope. We see here an action which Austrian, German, American Jews desire to set on foot in aid of their Galician brethren. Did such an interest of Jews for Jews of other states or of other tongues exist before the appearance of the Zionists? Was the connection which subsists between the destinies of the Jews of all lands so much as understood, let alone admitted? Nay, was not the very existence of a Jewish distress denied altogether? What have the Anti- and A-Zionists not taken into themselves in these last years out of the body of Zionist thought and — without admitting it, perhaps indeed without becoming conscious of it — given forth as their own! Already men begin to understand what Jewish distress is. Already it is known that it is not to be averted by the petty means of defence. Already the attempt is made with greater means; already a part of the well-to-do Jews becomes conscious of the duties of possession towards poverty, — yet still men shyly evade Zionism, the concluding proposition, although they acknowledge the premises themselves to be correct.
The founders of the Galician relief action expect from their undertaking a solution of the Galician Jewish question. In that case the success of their action would have led Zionism ad absurdum. We expect the contrary: that the Austrian "B'nai B'rith" in particular will, precisely through their activity, gather experiences which have hitherto been lacking to them; that they will above all attain to the perception that the questions of emigration, of unemployment, of the boycott can hardly be solved "within" the European countries even in the smallest measure, let alone in the great. He most easily finds the transition to Zionism who attempts, even in the least degree, really to perform Jewish deeds. It would assuredly be only a matter for rejoicing if, upon the path of the Galician relief action, we were to find ourselves together with the "B'nai B'rith" in Zionism.
*
Greatly as the news of the undertaking of the "B'nai B'rith" has rejoiced us, just as greatly has the constituent meeting of the Galician Relief Society disappointed us. It seems that the gentlemen have not for the present succeeded in drawing in wider circles of the bourgeoisie. For the participants in this first meeting belonged almost throughout to the lodges of the "B'nai B'rith" themselves; of representatives of the broad middle class there was nothing whatever to be seen. The whole manner of dispatching the order of the day made a very unfavourable impression. We will not judge over-hastily. But were we to let ourselves be determined solely by the impressions of this meeting, we should have to speak of a "still-born child". The report brought merely external details to the knowledge of the members. The adherence of the German and American lodges was reported, and it was finally summed up that the undertaking would, it was to be hoped, bring success. "To be sure," declared the reporter, "the relief action is only possible if the whole body of Jewry of all civilised lands co-operates therein."
Concerning that upon which it would properly have been necessary to report first of all — concerning the nature of the economic undertakings planned, concerning the result of any studies that may perhaps have preceded them in Galicia — nothing was made known. No more searching appreciation of the position of the Galician Jews, no statistical material, no expert utterances, no plans. We will assume that within the bosom of the founding committee the substance of the matter has already been pondered and deliberated upon. In the constituent meeting, at all events, not a word was spoken about it. And what was still more singular: although the report had lasted scarcely a few minutes, no participant in the meeting had interest enough to ask how and at what one ought to work. With justice a discontented but equally word-sparing man remarked in a corner: "It is sad that a matter which presupposes an activity reaching out over fifty or even a hundred years should be treated as though it were the founding of a veterans' club." In the stereotyped manner of that kind of society the election of the directorate was then carried through upon the proposal of the chair. On this occasion there was for a moment somewhat more warmth and animation. A participant in the meeting protested against filling the six places on the board which are reserved for Galicia once again with gentlemen (Dr. Byk and his fellows) who stand in a relation of political dependence upon the Polish Club and the Poles, and who have neither time nor heart for Judaism.
The meeting, however, declared itself tumultuously for Dr. Byk; the speaker was deprived of the floor, the close of the debate was moved and adopted, the election per acclamationem moved and adopted, and thereupon the meeting, after scarcely an hour's duration, was closed by the chairman with three sentences, one of which said neither more nor less than that this meeting was sitting "under the auspices of the whole body of Jewry ..."
If the spirit which hovers over this meeting is the spirit of the whole undertaking, then it is a pity to write one word more about it. Above all, the matter must be taken in hand seriously and thoroughly, or it had better not be taken in hand at all. Secondly: either the "B'nai B'rith" plan a work of charity, and then they may divide the parts of the alms-givers among themselves. Or else they desire to found a social-political undertaking, and then they must know that there are no longer any classes under tutelage, that social policy has nothing in common with charity, and that they must therefore also draw to counsel and to deed those for whom they mean to care, or at the least real, honestly Jewish representatives of the poorer classes. The Galician Jews — this the gentlemen ought surely to know by now — have long since had no confidence in the standard-bearers of assimilation. To place "Jewish Poles" at the head of a Galician undertaking means to discredit it from the outset. And in other respects too it is neither prudent nor seemly if the gentlemen — to call the child by its right name — remain "among themselves". If they are really conscious that they stand in need of the support of the whole body of Jewry, they must procure for a number of representatives of the people proper an entrance into the direction of the society and into its business. Here there is only an "either — or". Either the lodges of the "B'nei B'rith" remain what they were, exclusive charitable societies, or they desire to be more, the creators of Jewish social-political institutions, and then they must