No. 35 — "Die Welt" — Page 11.
(continued from page 10)
…newly redacted that the individual provisions are expressed in short and concise sentences.
-
An intimate connexion between shekel groups and societies on the one hand and the central body of the provincial organisation concerned is proposed, in such wise that the societies are charged, beside their ordinary list of members, to draw up and carefully to carry on a register of all shekel-payers to be found in their town (rayon or district). In one locality several local groups may also be founded with the sanction of the Provincial Committee.
-
The formation of the groups of a hundred into electoral groups devolves upon the Provincial Committees, which have for this purpose to keep a central list.
-
The Congress declares it desirable that a press committee be formed from the midst of the Congress, to which for this purpose a permanent press bureau in Vienna shall be subordinated.
-
The Congress declares the creation of a National Fund to be desirable, and charges the Actions Committee to undertake the introductory steps thereto.
Upon the motion to convoke the Congress only every two years, Dr. Herzl remarks that it would be advisable to pass only a resolution in this matter, since the case might arise that the Actions Committee should nevertheless be compelled to convoke the Congress in two consecutive years.
Dr. Auerbach moves a resolution by which it should be left to the Actions Committee whether it will convoke the Congress again in the coming year.
As this resolution is rejected, Dr. Herzl brings to the vote the question whether the Congress desires a fresh session in the coming year. It is thereupon resolved to hold a Congress again in the coming year. (Stormy applause.)
Against Prof. Gottheil's motion with regard to the Federation, W. Schur (Chicago) declares himself, since the several organisations must be left a free hand.
Mrs. Prof. Gottheil declares for this motion, because the societies which belong to no union are only a hindrance in the agitation.
Mr. Tunkle (Georgia) declares that in his conviction America and Canada are much too large for such an organisation to be carried through. The free development of the societies must everywhere be suffered, and they should stand in direct communication with the Actions Committee.
Maniloff (America) likewise declares for the freedom of the societies, and raises against the American Federation the reproach that it suppresses the freedom of the individual societies and prescribes to them the delegates to be elected for the Congress.
Prof. Dr. Gottheil declares that he has brought in this motion in the name of all the English-speaking Federations, and wonders that Mr. Schur in particular, who after all occupies a leading position in the North American Federation, should have declared himself against this motion. Freedom of development must indeed be preserved, but so great a movement must also have a centre. The Federation does not meddle in the internal affairs of the individual societies. For the rest, this motion refers merely to the English-speaking countries.
Leo Mozkin desires elucidation upon the reproaches raised by Mr. Maniloff against the "Federation of American Zionists."
Dr. Friedemann declares for Gottheil's motion, because in each country one can have to do with only one leader.
Prof. Dr. Gottheil meets the imputations raised by Mr. Maniloff, which are wholly unjustified. A proof of this lies in the fact that Mr. Maniloff has been sent to the Congress against the will of the American Federation.
Gordon (Liverpool) holds that the Federations accomplish nothing else than that they prescribe threefold and fourfold shekel taxes which the poorer Zionists cannot afford. These Federations are not the affair of the English-speaking delegates alone, but of all Zionists. (Applause.) He is indeed willing to admit that a centralisation is necessary; only, the attempts which have hitherto been made with the Federations have one and all miscarried.
Miss Bluestone (New-York) holds it, upon the ground of her long years of experience, to be impossible to accomplish anything profitable if the various societies do not join themselves together into a union. The Federations are the driving force, and at the moment when these fall asunder the whole work collapses as well. (Applause.)
Mr. J. Cowen (London) declares for the Federations in the interest of order and of discipline.
Maniloff repeats his reproaches that the American Federation suppresses the freedom of the individual societies.
Scheinkin (Russia) desires that the Congress may not occupy itself with questions which concern not the generality, but merely individual countries.
Dr. Gaster declares for the Federation. It is not correct, at least not as regards the English Federation, that it makes too great demands upon its members. The English Federation asks only two shillings, of which one is paid over as shekel to the Actions Committee and the other is employed for purposes of agitation. The costs of administration of the English Federation are defrayed not out of this money, but out of the private means of individuals. (Contradiction.) Only with united forces can anything be accomplished, but never with a dissipation of forces. If here, in so petty a matter, men cannot bring themselves to an organisation, how will the Jewish people ever unite upon a great question? (Assent.) The speaker has himself been convinced what great work the Federations accomplish. (Applause.)
Mr. Lennox Loewe (Johannesburg) declares himself against Gottheil's motion, and stands for granting to the poor man who gives but one shekel the same rights as to the rich. That, however, will not be the case if Gottheil's motion is raised by the Congress into a resolution. (Applause.)
President Dr. Herzl sets forth, without wishing to take up a position for or against the matter, the difficulties which must arise for the Actions Committee out of intercourse with every single society. In some way or other the individual societies must combine. Otherwise almost the whole of the shekel moneys would go in postage stamps (Assent), and moreover the inconveniences would assuredly increase without end. (Lively applause.)
The sitting is interrupted at 8 o'clock in the evening for one hour.
Night Sitting.
After the opening of the sitting, which took place towards a quarter past 9 o'clock in the evening through President Dr. Herzl, the chairman of the Permanence Commission, Dr. Bodenheimer, proposes, with regard to Prof. Gottheil's motion upon the Federations which was drawn into discussion in the afternoon, the following resolution, which stands in accord with the organisation statute: "The Congress declares that it is the duty of all the Zionist organisations of a country to attach themselves to the Provincial Federation; it further urgently recommends that the Federations be divided into districts, for which special organisations are to be created in agreement with the Federation. On the other hand, the Congress resolves that the future elections to the Congress be effected not through the delegates' conference of the Federations, but through the individual Zionist societies directly upon the spot, under the control of the Federations." (Lively applause.) Dr. Bodenheimer remarks hereto that he will have to withdraw this resolution by order of the Permanence Commission should the opening of a debate thereupon be demanded from any quarter.
As Mr. Cowen designates this resolution as unacceptable for England, and calls for the opening of the debate are raised from various quarters, Dr. Bodenheimer withdraws his resolution in the name of the Permanence Commission, whereupon a motion to pass to the order of the day over Gottheil's motion is adopted. (Lively applause.)
Rabbi Dr. M. Gaster (London), livelily acclaimed upon his appearance at the speaker's tribune, desires to speak upon the spiritual element in Zionism and to set forth briefly the philosophy of Zionism. Zionism has become a cultural movement within Jewry and within humanity. From our hope of leading our people into the land of its fathers we are gradually pushed further on to the immediate facts of life which are played out before our eyes. There approach us also questions of the immediate present which demand a solution from us. Out of the sad events in Roumania there has resulted a moral bankruptcy precisely upon that side in which the Jewish people has hitherto placed its whole confidence. The once more outstretched hands of the Alliances, to which