Die Welt · Vol. IV, No. 8 · 23 February 1900
3printed page
scan 3 of 16

No. 8 — "Die Welt" — Page 3

(continued from page 2)

…medium property has almost wholly crumbled away and is moreover purchasable only to a scarcely appreciable extent. Within the large landed property, too, a distinction must be drawn. The great latifundia owners will of course not give up their soil; on the contrary, they seek by every method, often not the most unexceptionable, to round off their possessions by purchases. There would remain, then, only the ill-managed estates of money-needing noblemen, often greatly depreciated by reckless exploitation.*) Now here and there one or another among these people is indeed to be met with who would like to hawk off "to the Jews," for a double or threefold overpayment, his possessions that have fallen so heavily in value. The story of such a "purchase" went the round of the papers but a short time since. On that occasion the Hirsch Foundation was the victim which a number of rich Polish and Vienna Jews, in league with the money-needing seller, had singled out for this purpose. From such purchases or similar transactions, however, one cannot after all conclude that the ruling Polish circles are willing — circles which employ every means, often even force, to prevent so much as a single really productive square metre of Galician soil from passing into "foreign" hands. Jews have indeed in earlier years acquired estates in Galicia, but to-day the economic and political conditions of Galicia are such that the acquisition of larger complexes of estates by Jews is simply not to be thought of. If one takes into account besides that antisemitism and asemitism in Galicia are in constant growth, and if one thinks further of the political and economic confusions towards which the whole of Austria, Galicia included, is moving, then one will comprehend why Dr. Tuch, who now with much zeal advocates the internal colonisation of Galicia, is in his latest pronouncements willing to content himself with the purchase of the estates already in Jewish hands. That, however, means restricting the projected action from the very outset in such a manner that it can hardly come into account any longer for an alleviation of the frightful distress among the Galician Jews. And withal it is by no means even probable that the Jewish landowners are inclined to support such a transaction. Quite apart from the costs, which through the acquisition of quite particular estates, upon which alone one would be thrown, would of course be driven up in a wholly disproportionate manner.

And withal there is as yet by no means agreement as to the manner in which the colonisation, even were it to proceed only upon a small scale, is actually to be undertaken. Whether the agricultural workers' productive co-operative society, for which Dr. Tuch with justice pleads so strongly, would also be chosen by the initiators of the action, is at the least very doubtful. And even were it to happen, it is, precisely after the statistical data given above, to be doubted whether upon so small a scale and under such conditions the attempt can be ventured at all. Oppenheimer assuredly did not think of Galicia and of the conditions there, which cannot be painted in colours crass enough, when he wrote of the remedy of the agricultural productive co-operative societies. But to expose a number of Jews, and were they but a few hundred, to the appetite for experiment of men however honourably minded — for that there is in truth, under present conditions, no occasion whatever. The decay of Galicia is manifest, if the husbanding of the country continues in the hitherto fashion. The oppression of the Ruthenians by the Poles, the exploitation of the people by the ruling class, the enforced assistance of the Jews in all those things which men fear to do alone, the hatred of oppressors and oppressed alike against the Jews, the struggle of the Schlachta not only for political hegemony but for its own existence — amid such confusions a colonisation of the Jews in Galicia can have no success. Indeed, even the native population can hardly hold its own in this struggle. With every year the emigration from Galicia grows, in spite of all prohibitions and impediments, and but lately a daily paper estimated the yearly emigration from Galicia at at least 8000 persons — far too low, no doubt. And the outflow is still insufficient. The Jewish population in particular is on the increase, in spite of the great misery, in spite of the high mortality among children. The immigration of foreign Jews may well have a share in this; in any case, however, as Nossig proves in his Materials, the fruitfulness of Jewish marriages contributes much to it. This circumstance too cannot be removed by the colonisation of a few hundreds in the country itself. But a larger number can, after our exposition, hardly be in question. With the number of individuals, however, the misery in Galicia grows also, quite apart from the economic conditions under which the Galician Jews languish.

Therefore there is one single radical, real help for the Galician Jews, and that is the emigration*) of the superfluous. The man or the group that can guide this emigration according to plan and bring it to a good end has alone the right to pass for a true friend and adviser of the Galician Jews. But whoever possesses strength and good will to wrest its victims from the terrible Jewish misery of Galicia will before all things seek to further this emigration by every means. It is a lofty thought to make these emigrants, if it be possible, into useful, settled citizens, into peasants. Certainly, out of the soil they and their descendants will win fresh strength and high courage, but not out of the soil of Galicia, which is grudged them and will never be given them in sufficient measure, but out of the soil which is holy to them, more perhaps than to the majority of the rest of the Jews, out of the soil which they are ready to manure not only with their sweat, but even with their blood, out of the soil of Palestine.

Those who remain behind, however, and who through the emigration gain room and air, will then perhaps be able to think of an internal colonisation with better success, or at least with more prospect of success. It is not meant thereby that the other economic organisation of the Jews of Galicia should also be postponed until the emigration has been carried out according to plan. Such an organisation in the economic field is urgently needful. There the other plans of the new friends of the Galician Jews may set in. Field enough for their activity is left them in truth.

Dr. Siegmund Werner.


The Speech of Herr v. Egan.

By Moritz Zobel.

At Munkács, a little town on the north-eastern frontier of Hungary, a significant speech has lately been delivered. Significant not so much on account of the official position of the speaker as rather on account of the subject which he discussed. The speech treated of us Jews, and in our days it matters pretty much alike who puts us into debate. To the interest of public opinion


*) In the year 1896 the encumbrance of the land-register property amounted to 28,430,828 fl.; the disencumbrance to 19,384,454 fl.

*) In the year 1899, 11,071 Jews from Austria-Hungary immigrated into America. One will hardly go wrong in ascribing ⁹/₁₀ of this sum to the Galician Jews.