Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 47 · 25 November 1898
9printed page
scan 9 of 16

No. 47

The Vienna Cultusgemeinde.

By B. Sopher.

This time the Jewish population awaits the cultus elections and their result with peculiar expectancy. It is not the candidates alone that make the interest so lively; the act of election in itself, the Cultusgemeinde as the representative body of the Jews, has acquired a renewed significance. In this, in the participation in Jewish communal affairs which now declares itself on every hand, the change of the times shows itself.

Yes indeed, there is an undeniable difference between former days and now. The relation of the greater part of the Jewish population to the Cultusgemeinde has hitherto been a loose and an indifferent one. To be sure, the causes of this are easily ascertained. They follow from the political history of the last decades, from the particular share of the Jews therein, but finally also from the languid activity of the Jewish community itself. Inasmuch as the Jew sought to attach himself to the more general movements, partly of a political, partly of a social kind, the Cultusgemeinde appeared to him as a remnant of an unedifying Judaism, which had been left over as though to vex him, in order to remind him upon manifold occasions, now of a joyful, now of a mournful sort, at birth or at death, at wedding or at burial, of his descent. Beyond this for the most part external relation, the Cultusgemeinde was regarded only as that place where the poor Jew from time to time received a support or an alms,

Of late, however, a noticeable transformation is taking place. Within the Cultusgemeinde itself, it is true, there is still too little of it to be felt, but the more so outside of it. And that is by far the more important thing. For everything depends above all upon the views which the Jewish population shares, not so much with regard to the temporary representatives of the Cultusgemeinde as with regard to its own purpose and destination. But the destination of every institution depends upon the value and the estimation set upon it. So long as the Cultusgemeinde was little regarded, its purposes might well be trifling, its destination insignificant. But at the moment when the population turns its full attention to the Cultusgemeinde, the situation is thoroughly altered: for not the individual alone, the community too "grows with its higher purposes." Of such purposes, and of earnest, very earnest tasks, there may in our days be very good reason to speak. We will begin with the question of instruction.

The instruction and the education of the Jewish youth belong quite properly to the sphere of action of the Cultusgemeinde. But here, as we have already once remarked, everything cries out for reform: the parents, the teachers, — there we said, the communities themselves, now we say: the people. The present-day representatives of an indifferent Judaism, in the working class, in the middle strata of the citizenry, in the circles of the money aristocracy and of the intelligence, let them be to us warning examples of what the coming generations must not be. Nothing is more painful than to hear these Jews speak about Judaism. To speak against one's own people, in order to thrust harshly from oneself everything that recalls it, to be done with it for ever — truly that is to rage against one's own nature. It cannot be suffered that the youth should further be educated in such a spirit, if spirit it is to be called. The tradition, the past of our people well deserve that we should know of them, know more than is commonly imparted to our youth in the scanty two hours a week. Our teachers of religion least of all are dawdlers. Religion, history, language — however fine, however necessary this union may be — with a time of instruction so briefly measured out, nothing profitable can possibly come of it. Should it then be wholly unthinkable to lay the foundation, at least, of a more national education deeper than has hitherto been done? To be sure, evil rumours are abroad that the mischief lies elsewhere too, in the preparatory schools for teachers of religion, in the theological seminary also. Of the qualification of the teachers no very good report is heard. How much warrant these rumours have, and how much they exaggerate, that we cannot decide; but the Cultusgemeinde well could. Something of it will surely have penetrated even to it. It is very praiseworthy that the Cultusgemeinde, as we have heard on occasion in assemblies, has always striven so to direct the religious instruction that it should not collide with the rest of the school instruction. Should it not also take thought that the religious instruction do not fall into collision with its duties, we may as well say with our duties, towards the Jewish people? The reproach of irreligiosity is now becoming a very favourite one with a part of our opponents. Well, we will not return it so simply. Religion — whatever it is and whatever it is not — in any case it is a very complicated phenomenon. Opinions precisely in religious matters diverge, as everyone knows, so frightfully sharply. There are, for example, people who would make the right of participation in communal affairs dependent upon one's attitude to the cultus, upon religion and the practice thereof. But certainly it would come hard to them to determine rigorously what they understand by religion, what observances of the cultus they would have followed. Whether, then, we are religious in their sense or not, that may be disputed: but when we demand for our Jewish youth more thorough instruction, better education, religious education too, then it is assuredly our wish and our will that the youth be religious, that the religious be cultivated.

Now we come to another matter, to the cultus tax and to the care of the poor. One would be inclined to emphasise almost every point one has just touched upon as the most important, because almost every part of the activity of the Cultusgemeinde stands in need of an alteration, of an improvement. Does not the Cultus Board itself admit in its last annual report that the Jewish population of Vienna is growing ever poorer, and that it is necessary to devote an increased attention to the relief of the poor? This, however, cannot come about so long as the administrative apparatus for the care of the poor remains one so wretched even in point of quantity as it is at present. In the electors' meetings this very point found expression often enough.

As regards the cultus tax, a lowering of the census must follow, and that in such a manner that all classes of the population, the poor also, may take part in the elections. Precisely the mass of the Jewish people, which in its religious and national activity represents the true Judaism, must also be able to exercise an immediate influence upon the Jewish Cultusgemeinde and upon the Jewish commonwealth.

Just now, too, is the right time to offer a few words upon the Cultusgemeinde as the representative body of the Jews. Not only because the elections are proceeding, but above all on the occasion of the school question.

The decree of the Vienna District School Board affords a quite particular occasion for it. All the steps which the Cultus Board has undertaken in this matter, beginning with the audience with the Minister of Public Instruction down to the presentation of a memorial, are certainly to be approved. But precisely in the treatment of this question — so far as this can be seen from the reports of the sittings — the right zeal is found wanting, which here would be very much in place. From the protest meetings of the Jewish population to the council chamber of the Cultusgemeinde the way seems to be somewhat long, somewhat fatiguing. By the immediate agitations of the Jewish population the members of the Cultus Board seem scarcely to be touched. On the other hand they are the more sensitively touched by the faintest criticism of their activity. But how well founded this criticism is, is shown by the programme which was drawn up by the united election committee. "Those wishes for reform which for years past have been voiced everywhere among the Jewish population" are now only the more loudly urged, because up to this time they have not been heard, much less fulfilled. We will not here repeat them once more one after another, the more so as we cannot here treat each one in detail. But summing up we will say: it will assuredly be nothing but conducive to the dignity of the Cultusgemeinde if it unfolds more energy within the bounds of its power and sphere of action. We expect too that this will come to pass in the future; for henceforth the contact between the Cultusgemeinde and the Jewish population will grow ever more active, let us say too more intimate. Whatever men may come forth from the urn, — the tasks that stand in need of solution and fulfilment are important ones, and they are not a few.

-Our teachers in earlier times, the Rabbis, were wont, before issuing certain ordinances, to follow the rule: "Look about thee out of doors, what the people says to it."*) Applied to the counsellors of the community, the saying would have to run: See what the people says, then wilt thou know what thou art to ordain, what at any time is needful. But rather still would we call out to them: Be yourselves the people, then will ye know it and fulfil it best.

Tribune.

An Appeal!

Whereas the undersigned society has resolved to convert the society's library into a public library, we address the most urgent request to all gentlemen authors, publishers, and booksellers, that they may contribute their mite to this work of common utility.

It would in the true sense of the word be called a אמת חסד של if they in this way to the promotion of the educa-

*) Lazarus, Ethik des Judenthums.