No. 31. — “Die Welt” — Page 3.
(continued from page 2)
…70/71. When at that time, in an epoch of high-running national excitement, Bebel took the part of the French against the Germans, of the Commune against the whole of Europe, he must surely have feared that he was throwing back the extension of his party to an incurable degree; but precisely in his inexorable consistency he could rely upon the natural organic development of social conditions, which in the end has indeed made his party the strongest in all Germany. In like manner the necessary development (the swelling of antisemitism) must make Zionism ever greater and more powerful, provided only that it remains true to its innermost being. Social Democracy has often been reproached with cynically hailing with joy the great-capitalist development which ruins thousands of independent existences and drives them into its ranks; Zionism may be reproached with wishing sufferings upon the Jews, so that they may become inclined towards its ideal. Neither is true. Neither the one nor the other desires this development, but it is there once for all, and both movements must reckon with it.
Of all political movements Zionism already displays the mildest, the most noble, one would like to say the most pious character, and it can do so in accordance with its very own being, which coincides with the necessary development and forces it into no posture of combat. It would hardly be possible to give any ground why precisely in the Dreyfus affair it should step out of this being.
Bismarck.
(1 April 1815—30 July 1898).
By S. Josephs.
In his essay “On Liberty” John Stuart Mill says: “It may seem better to be a John Knox than an Alcibiades; but better than either is it to be a Pericles. Had we such a one in our own days, he would assuredly not lack the excellences that were proper to a John Knox”. Germany had such a one. It was Bismarck. The great statecraft of Pericles he united with the unshakable, ruthless consistency of the Scottish Reformer. When at Knox's burial the Earl of Morton spoke the words: “Here lies the man who never feared the face of man”, that involuntarily recalls the utterance of Bismarck's that rings like a sword-stroke: “We Germans fear God, but nothing else in the world”. And the man who said that was using no mere phrase. A ruler by the grace of God, a prince out of the land of genius, he spoke otherwise and acted otherwise than the others about him and beneath him. He was as though cast in one mould, says the thoughtless panegyrist of him. And yet no one was more the product of a long and fortunate development than this man. What a difference between the student Bismarck, the Prussian Junker, and the mighty Chancellor! To be sure, one thing always remained recognisable in him and broke through victoriously in all the phases of his development: his strong, unbending individuality. And precisely that may have contributed not a little to making him so many enemies and sincere haters. “Originality”, says our philosopher, “forms no part of the ideal of the majority of moral and social reformers, but is rather felt jealously as a troublesome and perhaps also rebellious obstacle to that which these reformers regard as the best for mankind”. So Bismarck too passed with many for an obstacle, and beside mourning love there stands also triumphant hatred at his corpse. Though it does not break out in mob fashion, as in the camp of the Drumonts and the Rocheforts, it is no less deep in Germany. And, strange to say! Among the Jews it scarcely utters itself at all. They have indeed experienced very much evil from him. He was not kindly disposed towards them. For the first time he publicly took up a position against them when, on 14 June 1847 and on the following days, the draft of an ordinance was debated which concerned the condition of the Jews. A few citations from his speech of that time may find place here. He said, among other things: “I am no enemy of the Jews, and should they be my enemies, then I forgive them. Under certain circumstances I even love them. I grant them all rights too, only not that of holding a magisterial office in a Christian State ... Therefore, gentlemen, let us not take from the people its Christianity by showing it that Christianity is not requisite for its lawgivers ... .. I confess that I am full of prejudices. I have, as I said, sucked them in with my mother's milk, and I cannot succeed in disputing them away; for when I think of a Jew as the representative of the sacred Majesty of the King, a Jew whom I am to obey, then I must own that I should feel myself deeply depressed and bowed down ....”
At the close of the debate the question whether all the rights of the estates were to be granted to the Jews as to the Christians was in fact answered in the negative by 220 votes against 219. Even an amendment brought in at the following sitting, which conceded to the Jews the same rights with the exception of eligibility as deputies to the provincial diets, Bismarck opposed decidedly. Even at the division upon the rapporteur's report he declared: “It was merely my intention to dispute that the emancipation of the Jews is a step forward; for otherwise the Diet would have approved it.”
Thus the Jews knew from the first moment what they had to expect from Bismarck. From that time on he was to many of them the “medieval Junker with the antediluvian views”, just as to his political opponents he was, as the deputy von Beckerath once declared, a lost son of Germany. The sequel has proved how correct both these views were. Now the official Reichsanzeiger calls Bismarck the greatest son of Germany, and the Jews have learned to perceive that he was indeed their opponent, yet by no means out of antediluvian sentiment, but because he did not know them. He always maintained the standpoint that “a certain degree of positive Christianity is necessary for the common man”; from this standpoint he believed he must also refuse any fusion with the Jews. That explains, among other things, his attitude against civil marriage in the sitting of 15 November 1849. This attitude of refusal towards the Jews Bismarck never gave up. There were indeed among them men with whom he stood in friendly relations; he knew, indeed, how to value their capacities, and upon occasion how to make use of them as well; but the Jews will never be able to get over the fact that he always stood opposed to their full civic freedom. He was no antisemite in the current sense of the word. Out of the Junker there had grown a great statesman, who perhaps no longer approved his vehement and open stand of anno 1847; but the Jews were to him never much more than a figure in his great calculations, a figure which at most he set somewhat higher or brought out more sharply when it happened to suit his policy. For Jewish individuality he had, strangely enough, no understanding whatever, and countless times he misjudged and offended it, even when he had long since passed beyond the passionateness of his youth. But as a true man he knew how to hold manly dignity in high esteem in the Jew as well, and only a short time ago the well-known story went the round of the papers, how he once gave way respectfully before President Simson, who came of a Jewish family, when the latter, after an arrogant utterance of Bismarck's, appealed to the immemorial nobility of his Jewry. Less considerately, to be sure, did he deal with the Jewish parliamentarians who were his most embittered opponents. Nevertheless one may say that a self-