Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 24 · 17 June 1898
6printed page
scan 6 of 16

Page 6 — "Die Welt" — No. 24

(continued from page 5)

…Vienna, what has been said above holds good, and the payments for Austria-Hungary are to be sent to the banking firm J. & A. Brecher, Vienna, IX. Liechtensteinstraße 2.


The German Rabbinical Conference.

By Dr. Heinrich Loewe.

How, pray, did that singular product of political and rabbinical wisdom, the rabbis' protest against the Zionist movement, come into being? — When, a year ago now, the Congress was first summoned to the Bavarian capital, and the Jews of Munich already beheld in spirit the plundering of their otherwise so peaceably patriotic houses, their spiritual head, Rabbi Dr. Werner, held it to be a dictate of especial prudence that other rabbis besides himself should publicly oppose Zionism. He did not wish to stand alone, because he dared not. He therefore induced the members of the board of the German Rabbinical Union to issue a declaration which was to represent Zionism as contrary to religion. A colleague whose birthplace had stood in Polish districts hard upon the frontier of the Empire saw in this a favourable opportunity for documenting German-patriotic sentiment, and thus arose the second point of the protest, which was taken by so many Zionists and non-Zionists — presumably contrary to the intentions of its author — for a friendly denunciation in optima forma. The declaration of protest was sanctioned by the board of the Rabbinical Union and sent out. Vigorous replies were not wanting, and the board of the Union looked about for further accomplices, in confirmation of the old saying: "Solamen miseris socios habuisse malorum." For this reason the Union Conference had to sanction the protest at the cost of freedom of speech and of truth.

And yet a second and no less important reason determined this attitude of the Rabbinical Conference towards Zionism. When the Rabbinical Union was founded, Old Conservatives and Liberals had to be brought under one hat. This was done by laying down, as the 16th paragraph of the statutes, that all questions which had already found a decision within the "parties" should be excluded from the discussions of the Union. Since these are pretty well all the serious questions, those which one calls "religious", there was hereby created the unique phenomenon of a rabbinical society which excludes religious questions. Precisely the not discussing of religious questions, which the gentlemen rabbis charge against us as so grave a reproach, is the fundamental statute of their own society; and if with us it is a dictate of political prudence and of religious tolerance, with the rabbis it naturally presents itself as a contradiction against nature. The rabbis come together, and — religious questions are excluded. Here, then, it was most welcome that Zionism afforded the possibility of interesting deliberations; and had no Zionism existed hitherto, the German rabbis would have found themselves in the embarrassment of having to create one in order to be able to discuss it. Thus the history of the origin of the sublime Zionist debate also verges hard upon the ridiculous. Whoever, then, is in any measure initiated into the history of the origin of the declaration of protest will understand that here too the curse of the evil deed is that it must go on engendering evil.

This feeling stole over us most particularly during the report which Rabbi Dr. Horovitz of Frankfort-on-Main delivered upon Zionism. There was nothing left of the self-confident tone of the protest, which bears Dr. Horovitz's signature also. And that is quite natural. Dr. Horovitz passes for a far greater politician than rabbi. When it was desired to protest before the Congress, the scope of Jewish-national propaganda was still so little to be measured by those outside it that even a diplomatically trained and highly gifted head might be deceived. And Dr. Horovitz was deceived, thoroughly deceived. The protest was to coffin a still-born movement, and was only one of those salute-shots which are destined to receive the new and vigorous movement with noisy clamour before the public. Dr. Horovitz was deceived, and to-day would sign no such protest any more, had he not protested only too largely before the great public. His report was an extraordinarily skilfully masked retreat from the protest. He did not even give himself the trouble of seeking to prove the impossible, namely that our movement, as it finds expression in the "Basle Programme", runs counter to the messianic hopes of Israel for the future; and to cast doubt upon the patriotic sentiments of the party he found — be it said to his honour — not another word. He was obliged to acknowledge that the Jews are even to-day something more than what one calls a religious communion, and did not shrink from declaring openly that the Jews still form a nation to-day. By far the most essential part of his speech against Zionism might very well render useful service in a thoroughly Zionist propaganda pamphlet. For all that, amid all his bows before the honesty and the idealism of Zionist enthusiasm, he was constrained at the close of his speech to state that it was directed against Zionism; for without this assurance one was at times almost constrained to believe the contrary. Under the impression of his speech the co-reporter, our intimate opponent Dr. Vogelstein, was likewise constrained to join in all these bows before the honesty of the Zionists and to speak considerably more moderately than had doubtless been his intention. For otherwise he sees the salvation of Israel and of the world in the mission of replacing Hebrew prayers by German litanies, and believes that the Jewish question can be solved only amid the sound of the organ and the ringing of bells. His messianic hopes, too, are quite other than those of Dr. Horovitz, or indeed of Doctor Auerbach, who likewise felt themselves wounded by Zionism in their own, quite differently constituted ones. We will readily admit, however, that it testified to a certain dexterity to fabricate a declaration which in the letter says the same thing for both parties, but which in truth proceeds from two wholly opposed conceptions of the world. Finally Dr. Vogelstein found it indispensably necessary to sing a hymn of praise to the present colonisation in the Holy Land and to celebrate the society "Esra" as the non-Zionist stronghold of that colonisation. It is indeed a need with so many of these gentlemen to claim for themselves, contrary to their own inclinations, and after so many years of ignominious hostility, the colonisation which arose as the first manifestation of life of the Zionist movement. It is characteristic in this sense that on the second day of the proceedings a motion for the moral support of colonisation through the furtherance of the society "Esra" was recommended by the declaration from the committee table that this motion did but complete what had been spoken and resolved against Zionism on the preceding day. Absurd as this utterance was, it could of course, with such a mode of conducting business, give occasion to no discussion. Yet still more significant is the following little episode: When the motion for the support of "Esra" had been formulated on the Zionist side and signed by many friends and opponents of our party, Dr. Gustav Karpeles, seated at the journalists' table, recollected that his friend and fellow-thinker Dr. Vogelstein had but yesterday, in the struggle against Zionism, taken up the cause of the innocent "Esra" so warmly. He therefore held it his duty, and an obligation of decency, to induce Dr. Vogelstein also to set his signature to the Esra motion. And behold: Dr. Vogelstein refused most decidedly to do his friend this favour, and did not sign. What do you yourself call such a course of conduct, Rabbi Dr. Vogelstein?!

The gentlemen seemed indeed to have forgotten that they were deliberating before a certain public. It is true that in the preliminary conference it had been resolved, after heated debates for and against Zionism, that after the hearing of the reports no