Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 19.
(continued from page 1)
…enmity; you are as little called upon to give us counsel as to offer your counsel to the Storthing parties in Christiania."
That is our answer to those Jews whose programme runs briefly: "Disappear!" And we will also set them an example, whose imitation we beg of them. We do not combat them so long as they leave us alone. We do not seek to convince them of the falseness and the reprehensibleness of their tendency. We will place no obstacle in the way of their apostasy from Judaism. And yet we have an incomparably better right to occupy ourselves with them than they with us. For we feel ourselves to be Jews, which they do not, and to us therefore nothing Jewish is a matter of indifference, whereas with them that is doubtless the case. Not as though we had no opinion about their programme. Oh yes, we have an opinion upon it. We are convinced that their method does not solve the Jewish question. The individual who by baptism or in any other form shakes Judaism from him attains perhaps his purpose of sinking without a trace into the mass of his Christian fellow-countrymen. I say: perhaps; for in order that this should succeed, a whole number of conditions are required which are not found united over-often. The fugitive from Judaism must not dwell in a small place where the neighbourhood has known him and his family for generations; for in such surroundings he, and his descendants, will always remain, for several generations at the least, the baptised Jews, and will be precisely distinguished from the first-class, full-weight Aryans. He must therefore either be a bird of passage already from his parents and grandparents, or himself become a bird of passage; he must become a fugitive not only from his tribe but also from his accustomed human surroundings, else the warrant of Judaism follows him over into his new existence as well. Further, he must renounce every personal ambition; he must strictly deny himself all striving, in any field of human and civic activity, after the unfolding of his faculties, after success and renown. For if he distinguishes himself in the least degree, and thereby awakens the inevitable envy of outstripped fellow-aspirants, he may reckon with deadly certainty that his Jewish descent will be thrown between his legs, and that he will stumble over it precisely as he would have done had he remained the proud confessor of his Judaism — perhaps not more, but assuredly also not less. Thus, in order to be able to become an adoptive Aryan by the method of disappearance, of submersion, the individual Jew-shy Semite must be a wholly obscure personality, and must with iron constancy remain one his whole life long. He himself cannot hope to garner in his own lifetime the advantage which he promises himself from the denial of his tribe and of himself. This advantage accrues at most to his children or his children's children; the method therefore in fact comprises a great deal of music of the future, at least as much as Zionism, probably considerably more than it.
And observe, honoured assembly, that everything I have said hitherto holds only of the individual. So soon as the attempt is made to apply the method of sinking and disappearing on the great scale, one stands before a sheer impossibility, which does not really deserve to be discussed at all. In the first place, the great mass of the Jews will by no means let go of their Judaism, and even in this age of lukewarmness of faith would still rather suffer persecution and death than fall away from their faith, their traditions, their peculiar nationhood. But secondly, even if the incredible were to happen, if the Jews were minded to resolve stoically upon a suicide of the people, this uttermost deed of despair would avail them nothing. It would turn out that they are insoluble in Aryandom. They would no longer be Jews, but they would be Jew-Christians, and anti-Semitism would turn against the Jews disguised as Christians precisely as it now turns against the Jews in their honest own dress. Yet we need not express ourselves conditionally and by way of conjecture at all. We can appeal to palpable historical facts. The descendants of the adherents of Sabbatai Zewi, who 230 years ago went over to Islam in Salonica, form to this day a community by themselves, sharply separated from the Turks. The Polish Frankists, who more than four generations ago became Catholics, have to this day preserved their peculiar Semitic physiognomy, and no national Pole confounds them with Sarmatians. Wherever Jews in greater number were converted at the same time to another faith, there they remained a peculiar group, as easily and surely recognisable in the midst of their new co-religionists as the water of the great South American rivers in the midst of the waters of the Atlantic Ocean. At the edges a slight crumbling gradually takes place, which leads to a slow blurring of the lines of division. But the centre remains unblurred for an incalculable length of time. Experiences of this kind justify the assertion that the programme of sinking and disappearing is incomparably more fabulous than that of Zionism. To revive the Jewish people to a political existence upon the firm foundation of a landed property of its own, under the guarantee of the Great Powers, may be difficult, is certainly difficult. But to dissolve the Jewish people into the European nations to the point of imperceptibility is impossible.
That, then, is our answer to those critics and opponents of Zionism who desire the disappearance of the Jewish people. We say to them: "In the first place your solution is incomparably more chimerical than the Zionist one, for nine-tenths of the Jews wish to remain Jews, and even if they wished to cease being Jews, anti-Semitism would recognise them behind every mass-disguise and would persecute them further. But in the second place it is really too kind of us that we enter into a discussion with you and into a refutation of your singular views. Your programme excludes you from Judaism. Zionism, however, is an internal question of Jewry. So pray concern yourselves with your own affairs, and be so good as to leave it to us to look after ours ourselves."
Now we come to those opponents of Zionism who really or ostensibly desire the preservation of Judaism. Their objections may be summed up in these three propositions of subsiding vehemence: Zionism is an impracticable madness. Zionism is a danger for Judaism. Zionism is unnecessary, and Judaism will continue to exist without it, as it has existed for eighteen centuries. One hears, indeed, two other objections as well, which I should like to call the mystical ones. It is to interfere in the plans of Providence, it is said, if the Jews rouse themselves to self-redemption instead of waiting submissively for the appearance of the promised Messiah. To this criticism I cannot reply, because it speaks a language which I do not understand and do not speak. Perhaps scribes may be found who can prove to the unctuous pious out of all manner of chapters and verses that they misunderstand the promises of the prophets. And if it does not succeed in convincing them, we shall be content with that too. For, honestly speaking, these humbly enduring and hoping folk, who lay their hands in their lap and wait until a fist out of the clouds takes them by the scruff of the neck and carries them through the air into the Land of Promise, are no desirable element in a people which must stir itself vigorously in order to build up, with resolute self-help, a new and viable commonwealth. The second mystical objection is that the Jews