No. 11. — "Die Welt" — Page 7.
(continued from page 6)
…I take my seat, I feel bound to acknowledge the great impetus which Zionism has gained since the beginning of Dr. Herzl's activity. Although on some points concerning the Jewish polity I do not agree with Dr. Herzl, this in no way disturbs our friendship, for so it should be among Zionists."
Thereupon Mr. J. de Haas read out a letter which Dr. Herzl had addressed to the assembly.
Mr. Josef Prag rendered a report upon the hitherto — and in any case well-known — activity of the Paris Committee.
The address of Colonel Conder, at present the best authority on the geography of Palestine, upon the history of the Jews in Palestine was read out by Rev. Hermann Gollancz. The detailed contents of this address, which describes minutely the political vicissitudes of the Palestinian Jews, we shall supply in the next number.
Dr. S. A. Hirsch, the deserving secretary of the "Chovevi Zion Association," in his paper "Zionism and the National Idea," maintained the national standpoint decidedly. The word "Zion" was to him more than a mere word or an allegory; it was to him "a living fact, a living organisation." "Zionism contains within itself our hopes of a rebirth of our race and of a restoration of Israel." Therefore the Holy Land also was for us body and spirit.
A question as to Jewish nationality could not exist. The Jews are a nation. What binds them to one another was our religion, our land, our language, our literature, our glorious and unexampled history.
The "Protest-Rabbis" fared none too well. Dr. Hirsch recalled the exodus of the Jews under Ezra, which these gentlemen "would certainly not have approved." They are indeed at pains to separate religion from nationality, and yet in Judaism these are inseparable conceptions. The speaker also combated the senseless view, which appears to be current not on the Continent alone, that nationalism is decried as a step backward as soon as it is the Jewish nation that is in question, "whereas in other cases, where it is a matter of comporting oneself as an Englishman, a Frenchman, a Siamese, a Patagonian, or the like, it is regarded as a virtue. With an enthusiastic appeal to remain true to Zionism and to Jewish nationalism, this address, which was received with unanimous applause, was brought to a close.
Now the discussion began. Dr. Hirsch moved:
"The conference is of opinion that the national idea forms an integral part of Zionism."
To this J. de Haas moved an amendment:
"The conference is of opinion that the national idea forms an integral part of the Zionist movement, and that it is the duty of all Jews to unite for the purpose of a lawful resettlement of the Jewish people in Palestine."
This wording, after a thorough discussion, was adopted as a resolution by 95 votes against 6. With an expression of thanks from Chief-Rabbi Gaster to the chairman, the morning sitting closed.
An improvised concert, at which Hebrew poems and songs were performed, formed the transition to the
Afternoon Sitting.
The chair was taken by Mr. Josef Prag, who also rendered his report upon the present state of colonisation in Palestine. In it we find an exact description of the several colonies and of their development. Mr. Prag closed with the following motion:
"This conference is of opinion that the colonisation of Palestine should be continued by the support of the existing colonies, by the settlement of the Jews living in Palestine as tillers of the soil, and, if possible, by the encouragement of bodies that desire to establish colonies in Palestine."
Mr. Rabbinovicz (president of the London-East branch) supports this motion.
Mr. Halpern (delegate of the "Borshei Zion Association" in Liverpool) moves the following addition:
"It is desirable that the existing colonies be protected and supported so far as possible, but the efforts must be directed chiefly to carrying the political-Zionist movement forward."
Mr. Rosenzweig (Liverpool) supports the supplementary motion. Mr. Ish-Kishor is against it. J. de Haas moves, in place of "if possible," the clause "without the general movement being thereby disturbed." This wording of the resolution is supported by Dr. Gaster and adopted.
Mr. Ish-Kishor then delivered an address upon "Hebrew as a Living Language." He described the advance which the Hebrew language and literature have made in the last decades, named the eminent poets and publicists who have laboured in this field, and laid down the following postulates:
-
The support of the public schools in which Hebrew is taught as a special subject;
-
the application of the newest methods of instruction;
-
the creation of a fund for instruction;
-
the founding of an institution of honorary examining commissioners;
-
the opening of libraries and reading-halls;
-
the encouragement of societies and bodies for Hebrew conversation.
Thereupon the following resolution was adopted:
"The conference recommends to the headquarters of the 'Chovevi Zion Association' the formation of a special committee for the spread of Hebrew as a living language through the support of the schools in question, and expects that it will devote its particular attention to the 'Beth Hasepher' in Jaffa."
Evening Sitting.
The chair was taken by Mr. H. Bentwich, in order that he might himself deliver an address upon the position and the prospects of Zionism in England. The speaker first touched upon the rise of the "Chovevi Zion Association" thirteen years ago and its development up to its present number of branches, women's societies, and academic circles. He recalled the petition of the English Jews, which was to reach Lord Salisbury through Lord Rothschild and then the Grand Signior, and of which Sir Montagu, as chairman of this assembly, said that it would bring about not only a furtherance of colonisation, but also a practical advancement of the Jewish aspirations towards the establishment of a Jewish polity. The Association had also collected money in order to found an English colony of its own, without having succeeded in this. Through the "Judenstaat" Zionism was then placed upon a much broader and more general basis. Mr. Bentwich then set forth the grounds of Zionism, its importance for the ethical elevation, physical regeneration, and material redemption of the Jewish masses "in our ancient homeland," and closed with an appeal for unity. He met with very much applause.
Upon the so important question of the "Reorganisation of the Chovevi Zion Association" there reported the untiringly active Zionist agitator and journalist Jacob de Haas. He called the conference an echo, one of the many echoes of the Basle Congress. The Zionist movement was a movement of the people, which had to fear not the wrath of the rich, but the indifferentism of the masses. And this conference was precisely a protest against indifferentism, lethargy, and submissiveness. This conference should also be the means by which not merely various opinions are expressed, but by which a persecuted nation may also obtain a hearing. For this purpose, however, a close-knit unity was needful. In order to attain this, the speaker proposed a "Federation" in place of the "Association." It should comprise all the Zionist societies of Great Britain and stand under the direction of an executive committee elected by the conference, which was to meet half-yearly or yearly. The minimum