Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 27.
(continued from page 5)
...Antisemitism" has surely proven himself a faithful friend! One must praise the man who possesses the quality of loyalty. We should therefore certainly be acting ignobly if we did not let justice be done even to our enemy.
Well then, Drumont lets his friend defend himself, and even condescends to defend him with his own pen. This defense, to be sure, is a trifle feeble. When one reads Drumont's articles, one might almost say that he is afraid of letting himself become too deeply entangled in the affair; it seems that he wishes to await the course of events. But when all is said and done, his journal does stand open to the anonymous articles of Walsin-Esterhazy. For it was before he was named by the brother of Dreyfus that "Dixi," alias Walsin-Esterhazy, sought to gain the head start. By a small, or perhaps also a great, exertion of his imagination he made a discovery. It is, to be sure, not very original, but, good heavens, such a sorry hero as ours is surely not obliged to be original into the bargain. For he declared, at the outset of his article, that Dreyfus had never ceased to correspond secretly with foreign parts.
It is quite useless to waste a word upon what stupidity such an assertion presupposes in the readers to whom it is served up. But probably the "Libre Parole" knows its readers and knows what may be offered them.
The said writer of the article declares further, with regard to the Dreyfus affair, that at the last moment the procedure had been revealed to the Dreyfus family and to his defenders of which the traitor had availed himself in his correspondence with foreign parts. He imitated the handwriting of an officer whom he did not personally know at all. Now, it was said, the tireless exertions of the Dreyfus Syndicate — "You know, my dear readers, that such a Dreyfus Syndicate really does exist!" — had succeeded in finding the officer whose handwriting "the abominable traitor" had made use of. This handwriting, too, was that displayed in the notorious bordereau of the indictment. And it was precisely this unfortunate officer, who had been tracked down by chance, whom the "Dreyfus gang" had chosen as their scapegoat, in order to shift onto him the guilt of the "Jewish traitor."
Is it Esterhazy himself who invented this swindle, or is it one of the "veiled ladies" who suggested it to him — we shall probably know before long. This whole story is for the moment not so important. What is important is the existence of these veiled ladies. It is as an English journalist recently said: "The Dreyfus affair is becoming a veritable realistic novel." And did not Emile Zola but just now write in the "Figaro" that "in view of these developments of a positively tragic beauty which life sets before us, the heart of the novelist beats with passionate admiration"?
The article of "Dixi," then, was an answer, or at least laid claim to being an answer, to the disclosures of the "Figaro," which undoubtedly emanate from Scheurer-Kestner. But this combat against anonymous parties, in which to an "I saw" one answered "I said" — which was to mean, I intend to defend myself by words, whatever they may be — this combat with masked countenance was bound to assume a disquieting character, considering that suspicion might fall upon wholly innocent persons. And indeed there had already begun, with all the more inexcusable levity because it occurred in an otherwise very temperate newspaper, the "Liberté," the naming of an honorable officer, M. Denis de Rougemont.
For this reason the mask had to be thrown off, and open war declared upon the criminal who still dared to raise his head. This Mathieu Dreyfus did, with the consent of M. Demange, the defender of the condemned man. The letter by which Mathieu Dreyfus laid his charge against Walsin-Esterhazy had quite the effect of a coup de théâtre. Now the government stood before a formal accusation. What else remained for it to do but to open an investigation?
With Mathieu Dreyfus's charge there coincides in point of time the letter of Scheurer-Kestner to one of his friends and colleagues in the Senate. Scheurer-Kestner's silence was very much held against him. Why does he keep silent? Why does he not tell what he knows about the matter? From this the enemies of Captain Dreyfus concluded that there was a complete lack of documents and of material evidence in favor of the man deported to Devil's Island. "M. Scheurer-Kestner is not to be moved to open his portfolio — for his dossier contains nothing!" And in order to emphasize this thoroughly, this "nothing" was repeated three times. All the Boulangist and antisemitic journals, and those which awaited a delegate of the alleged Dreyfus Syndicate — they will have to go on waiting for this mythical person of a still more mythical syndicate — they all cried on and on in chorus: "Nothing, nothing, nothing!"
But Scheurer-Kestner suddenly declared in his letter that he had kept silent only because the Minister of War had asked him to do so, setting him a term of fourteen days. This letter was a blow straight in the face of the Minister of War. The Chamber could now no longer remain indifferent. A question was addressed to the Ministry. The Minister of War answered it with an ambiguous and very confused declaration. Out of this declaration, however, there emerged a very important fact. Whereas formerly the semi-official and official pronouncements of the government had always insisted that Dreyfus had been condemned according to law and justice, the Minister of War, in view of Scheurer-Kestner's letters, no longer dared to speak of the legality and justice of the Dreyfus condemnation. Thereupon the wildest outbursts of fury showed themselves in the camp of Esterhazy, while the defenders of the unfortunate captain declared themselves satisfied. And so an investigation was opened anew. But this was what Scheurer-Kestner had demanded of the Minister of War from the very beginning. For ten days now this investigation has been conducted by General Pellieux.
It has not yet been mentioned that Walsin-Esterhazy accused Colonel Picquart, the former chief of the bureau in the General Staff, of having allegedly hatched a plot against him. Colonel Picquart was transferred by way of punishment to Tunis last summer, because he had dared to give expression to his opinion of the innocence of Captain Dreyfus.
The colonel had at the time, in his position as chief of the bureau of the General Staff, been charged with making inquiries concerning Major Walsin-Esterhazy. These inquiries one day brought numerous letters of Walsin-Esterhazy into his possession. He was fairly thunderstruck by the alarming resemblance of Walsin-Esterhazy's handwriting to the characters of the bordereau ascribed to Captain Dreyfus. The colonel turned to his superior, General Gonse, and laid the following before him: Either Dreyfus was condemned solely and exclusively on the strength of the bordereau, in which case it is not he who ought to have been condemned, but Esterhazy, whose handwriting shows no deviation from that of the bordereau; or Dreyfus was condemned on the strength of a secret communication to the court-martial, which was brought forward in the absence of the accused and his defender, in which case the proceedings are illegal. In either case the revision of the trial cannot be evaded." This was, to be sure, a flawless piece of logic. As his reward for formulating this either-or, Picquart fell into disgrace and was sent to Africa. General Gonse himself said one day to the colonel: "What concern of yours, really, is the Dreyfus affair? Do keep silent!" Whereupon the brave officer answered: "Rest assured that I shall not take with me into my grave the secret that lies over this matter."
That is just it. Colonel Picquart knows the riddle of all these dark machinations which make up the Dreyfus affair.
After he had been formally accused by Mathieu Dreyfus, Esterhazy shifted the whole accusation onto Picquart. According to Esterhazy, the colonel had sold himself to the Dreyfus Syndicate and had furnished it with the secret documents that had been in his possession when he was chief of the bureau in the General Staff. At the same time that he was inculpating Picquart, Esterhazy handed over to the Minister of War the photograph of a document, which was supposed to be of such a nature as to prove the irrefutable guilt of Captain Dreyfus. Whence did he obtain this piece?
Here we enter into a chapter of romance of the sort that Ponson de Terraille used to write. A veiled lady, so some maintain, had given Esterhazy a rendezvous behind the church of the Sacré-Coeur at Montmartre; others, again, that the rendezvous had taken place behind the Alexander III bridge, which is even now being erected for the Exhibition of 1900.
This was, once for all, quite to the taste of the Boulevard as well as of the Faubourg. From that point on the matter became truly interesting to them, and dreadfully thrilling to the nerves. In truth it was a vulgarly composed page in a book