Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 25 · 19 November 1897
6printed page
scan 10 of 20

Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 25.

(continued from page 5)

…consequences remain legally in force. It can be set aside only by a decision of revision conformable to the provisions of Article 443 of the Penal Code — as modified by the Law of 8 June 1895. Under the terms of that law, the right to demand a revision belongs to the Minister of Justice: "when, after a conviction, a fact is adduced or discovered, or pieces of evidence which were unknown at the time of the proceedings and are now brought forward, are of such a nature as to establish the innocence of the convicted man." — Since the Minister of Justice has been apprised of no new fact and of no piece of evidence hitherto unknown, the Government can do nothing but leave the judgment further in force."

To understand this note, it must be observed that Herr Scheurer-Kestner has not handed over to the Government the pieces of evidence which are in his possession and which establish the innocence of Dreyfus. The Vice-President of the Senate contented himself with communicating to the Prime Minister Méline and to the Minister of War Billot the existence of the evidence he possesses.

From this moment the Dreyfus Affair enters upon an entirely new stage.

A year ago the possibility of a revision of the Dreyfus trial would have seemed to everyone a chimera. To-day the Government itself, by holding strictly to the judgment pronounced by the court-martial, which it is bound to carry out, shows Herr Scheurer-Kestner the means of obtaining the revision.

Since the matter is not one of a mere conviction on the part of Herr Scheurer-Kestner, but of a sure demonstration, the hope is justified that the pieces of evidence upon which he relies will bring to light the innocence of the deported man of Devil's Island.

That these pieces of evidence really exist admits of no doubt for Herr Bernard Lazare. Bernard Lazare has, with a courage and a fire that are truly incomparable, taken the cause of Captain Dreyfus into his hands in the past year. It is rather the cause of justice and equity than that of Captain Dreyfus. Bernard Lazare, who is perfectly informed, is assuredly not deceiving himself.

While one awaits the disclosures of Scheurer-Kestner, our friend Bernard Lazare has just published a second book upon the miscarriage of justice committed by the court-martial. It is a book of more than 300 pages.*) It contains a memorandum by Bernard Lazare, nine opinions of handwriting experts, a critique of Bertillon's opinion, a facsimile of the incriminating document, and 17 letters of Captain Dreyfus.

Bernard Lazare's memorandum is preceded by a preface containing a letter from Captain Dreyfus's counsel, Herr Demange, who has never ceased to believe in the innocence of the convicted man. M. Demange confirms once more that he has never known of any charges against Captain Dreyfus other than those discussed by Bernard Lazare (that is, the notorious bordereau). As for Bernard Lazare's assurances that a communication was made to the judges in the absence of the accused and of his counsel, Herr Demange does not venture to believe it. He adds further: "My best wishes are with you, and if I have maintained complete silence towards all those who wished to converse with me about the Dreyfus Affair, it was not because my innermost conviction of his innocence had been shaken; it is rather the only way for me to reconcile that absolute conviction with the respect which I owe to a judgment already rendered."


*) The title runs: "A Miscarriage of Justice. The Dreyfus Affair." By Bernard Lazare. Paris 1897. (303 pages in large octavo.)

This irrefutable testimony of the man who of all others is most called upon to speak confirms what Herr Bernard Lazare has always said and still maintains to-day: "The sole 'proof' brought forward against Captain Dreyfus rests upon the opinion of the handwriting experts. "I do not know," says Herr Bernard Lazare, "whether Herr Demange even to-day still doubts that a secret communication was made in the court-martial which condemned Captain Dreyfus. "I have never known of any charges against Captain Dreyfus," says the celebrated advocate, "other than those you have mentioned." Will anyone bring doubt against his word? Who will be able to do so without thereby admitting that he was left in ignorance of certain facts or of particular pieces of evidence — that is, without thereby accusing the judges of not having wholly fulfilled their duty? A year ago already Bernard Lazare declared that Captain Dreyfus was condemned in consequence of a single piece of evidence. To-day he has furnished the strict proof that this single piece of evidence brought forward by the prosecution turns in irrefutable, triumphant fashion against the prosecution itself. It thus appears that a man was placed before the court-martial through an unhappy concatenation of incredible errors, and that in consequence of suspicions frivolously raised and by no means legally established he was cast out from human society. One will now be astonished that it took so long for the truth to come to light. This single piece of evidence of which we speak consists in the well-known document. But here perhaps a little retrospect upon the history of this trial is necessary. — One day it was noticed at the Ministry of War that documents had gone missing; evidently they had been delivered to a foreign Power. Who could have done it? Now, there is a Jew on the General Staff. A Frenchman — so the leading personages reason to themselves — is surely not capable of such a crime! Therefore the Jew must be the guilty party. And now every means was employed to fasten it upon the Jew. One day there is further found, in a waste-basket of the embassy of a foreign Power, a paper torn into four pieces. The spy who was charged with procuring this paper does in fact bring it to the Ministry of War. The document is examined; the handwriting resembles that of Captain Dreyfus. So there is no further doubt: it is really the Jew who has betrayed the fatherland. A military examining magistrate is charged with instituting the judicial inquiry. This judge was an officer named Paty de Clam. This man conducted the inquiry with a partiality without equal. The Minister of War encouraged him in it besides. — The affair, which until then had been kept secret, now became noised abroad. Who, then, was first to bring the news of the arrest of Captain Dreyfus? The first journal that reported the arrest of Captain Dreyfus was the "Libre Parole". The news was conveyed to it on the 28th of October by an anonymous letter. On the 29th of October 1894 Drumont's journal inquired whether it were true that an important arrest had taken place. Several journals reproduced this notice; but the only one informed was the "Libre Parole"; the author of the anonymous letter knew well what he was doing — that the victim, once Drumont had seized upon the matter, would no longer be able to escape. On the 1st of November the anti-Semitic sheet accordingly announced with a great tam-tam the arrest of a Jewish officer, adducing data which persons not belonging to the military court could not possibly have communicated.

"How then, since at the Ministry of War itself only a quite limited circle of persons knew of the arrest of the