No. 13. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
…question could in any way be thought of. The Germans, the French, the Russians must therefore first sit firm and secure upon their inherited soil, without having anything to fear from the national neighbour. Nor may they come into personal contact with him too often, since otherwise, for all their common European culture, the innermost oppositions of temperament and national character would very soon break through. The need for an opposition, for an Above and a Below, as also for an Either — Or, is rooted far too deeply and eternally in human nature ever to be extirpated. Should we really once be rid of the struggle for the feeding-trough, then vanity and ambition, groundless instinctive sympathies and antipathies, will step into the lists. The Socialist who will not believe this must nevertheless admit that at present the social class struggle is materially sharpened by such uncontrollable stirrings of the sub-consciousness. Already the national hatred of the European peoples for one another plays a considerable part in their economic policy and disturbs the purity of the Socialist experiment. But this clouding is mere child's play beside the boundless confusion which is wont to arise as soon as the wretched Jew-hatred comes into action. Even the German Social Democrats, who dispose of the most thoroughly schooled and best disciplined party troop in the world, have trouble enough to keep their comrades as free as possible from antisemitic stirrings. The Social Democrats in Austria do not venture upon such an attempt at all, and prefer to shut both eyes when the working masses pour a little antisemitic brandy into the wine of their Marxism. Were there no Jews in Austria and no Jew-hatred either, the Social Democrats would long since have gained twice the number of votes. The German Social Democrats, too, would then not find so many cudgels in their path. The middle class, so far as it is still viable, would long ago have fallen to them, and those elements which are doomed to destruction could scarcely find the strength for a serious resistance without the far-carrying resonance of Jew-hatred. The Social Democrats, therefore, in order to hasten that course of development of bourgeois society which they have constructed and which they long for, have the greatest interest in getting the Jewish question out of the world as quickly as possible.
A far greater interest still is of course held by those young German Jews who have grown much too firmly together with the German character ever to get free of it. Somewhere Goethe says that no man is rid of that which belongs to him, even though he cast it away. By antisemitic Germany these young Jews are continually rejected and cast away — they remain Germans. But they also endure torments of soul of the most frightful kind, and seize upon the strangest expedients to help themselves. They either cry out about Semitic bad habits even far louder than the antisemites do, or they put their heads in the sand and pursue an ostrich policy. However different these methods may appear, their representatives nevertheless confound cause and effect in precisely the same manner, and set themselves obstinately upon Utopian impossibilities. Both parties evidently believe that real or invented Jewish vices were the cause of antisemitism. But antisemitism does not arise because the Jews have bad qualities; rather, because the age-old Jew-hatred still persists, so many bad qualities are downright imputed to them, or at least reckoned far more heavily against them than against any other citizen of the State. It is therefore entirely superfluous to call a resounding "Hear, O Israel" into the wood. Even if Israel really did hear, and alone of all the peoples of this earth contrived to have no rogues and knaves in its midst — Jew-hatred would soon find out something else. And it remains a truth that the Jews cannot be "model boys" either. To be sure, the defence-men of Herr Rickert's school sometimes strike a note that one thinks involuntarily and ironically of the well-known verse: "This child — no angel is so pure." This stupid exaggeration offers the lurking adversary the worst openings, and moreover it would be of no use even if it were true. It is simply a quite incomprehensible, rationalistic error to hope to get at age-old instincts and antipathies by refutation and instruction. But lately a witty writer attempted in the "Berliner Tageblatt," by means of a not at all bad rationalistic parable, to reduce antisemitism ad absurdum. If in Berlin, so he framed it, some eighty thousand persons were condemned always to carry a placard upon their backs, there would soon form between them and the population an opposition, if not direct enmity. As soon as — and it cannot possibly be otherwise — knaves also turned up among these eighty thousand placard-men, it would at once be said, in unison, among the public: Well, yes, one of those placard-men. Otto Ernst, without knowing it, has hit the nail on the head with this parable. For the Jews really are, in comparison with the Indo-Germanic Europeans, veritable placard-men. Their face is the placard, upon which not the caprice of men, but eternal nature and the development of two thousand years have written. It is wholly idle to dispute whether the Jews are pure Semites or whether Aryan-Alarodian blood also flows in their veins. Enough, they are other than the peoples among whom they live. And because they are other, strong antipathies are released against them, and antisemitism will only disappear when this differently constituted people either sits upon its own soil or is absorbed without trace into the host peoples. Toward this goal the young German Jews ought to work energetically, instead of moralizing indignation in an intolerably oracular tone about Semites and antisemites. But when these young Jews have recognised the right road, then willy-nilly they too will have to come to terms with Zionism — just as must the Social Democrats, who perceive that a removal of Jew-hatred can only benefit themselves and the international solution of the social question.
What does Zionism want? It wants to create for such Jews as cannot or will not assimilate themselves in the land of their birth a home guaranteed in public law. By no means, then, as people fable, for all Jews. Whoever has the prospect of being completely assimilated in the land of his birth, or feels himself perfectly grown together with the culture that surrounds him, shall not be torn out with a brutal hand and forced into a clumsy, stupid chauvinism. Unfortunately millions of Jews, especially in Eastern Europe, are not in this position. Even if they wished, they could not assimilate themselves — the host peoples plainly wave them off. What, then, is to become of these Jews? Their situation grows to the point of unendurability, and they stream away to lands which appear to offer more favourable conditions. In Germany matters still stand substantially better than in Russia, and so, year in, year out, countless Russian and Polish Jews cross the German frontier. Their German-born "co-religionists" assuredly do not fail in support and benevolence of every kind — above all they provide travelling money to America, so that the poor fugitives soon turn their backs upon the German land as well. For to these benefactors, though they do not readily admit it, the uninterrupted influx of Russo-Polish Jews is in the highest degree awkward, because they know very well that this emigration puts fresh weapons into the hands of their antisemitic opponents and makes assimilation vastly more difficult. Perfectly correct. But, one must ask, are the Jews in Russia, Poland and Roumania, in order not to disturb their German brethren's pleasure,