Die Welt.
No. 9. Vol. I.
Editorial Office and Administration: Vienna, II., Rembrandstrasse 11.
Advertising rates: the four-column petit line, 10 kr.
Published every Friday.
Vienna, 30 July 1897.
Communications are to be addressed not to individual persons, but to the Editorial Office or the Administration, Vienna, II., Rembrandtstrasse 11.
Unstamped letters will not be accepted, and manuscripts will not be returned.
Subscription rates. For Austria-Hungary: half-yearly 3 fl. = 6 Kr.; yearly 6 fl. = 12 Kr. For abroad: half-yearly 4 fl. = 8 Kr.; yearly 8 fl. = 16 Kr. Single numbers 15 kr.
German Rabbis.
By Dr. J. Rülf (Memel).
The Reverend Dr. Leimdörfer of Hamburg has likewise felt himself obliged to publish in the „Allg. Ztg. des Judenth." a pronouncement against Zionism and national Judaism, and that in a gibberish which would draw a smile from us, if such play-acting, phrase-mongering, cloak-bearing conduct did not have to be regarded as the peculiar mark of a degenerate party within Judaism, and above all within German Judaism. Doctors Maybaum and Vogelstein are quite other fellows; they at least are men of sense, with whom a sensible word may be exchanged.
"As a teacher in Israel who fights for the honour of Judaism," — so Dr. Leimdörfer begins his twaddle. The man calls himself a teacher in Israel, only to deny, to disdain, to betray this same Israel a few lines further on. But that is the logic of all these people; their life and their doctrine, their praying and their preaching are rooted fast and ineradicably in the soil of national Judaism, yet when it comes to holding the national flag and colour aloft and bearing them openly, then they shrink back and cry: We are no Jewish people at all, we are only a Jewish religious communion. To be sure, to be sure, they say with the prophets: "I must after all go after my lovers, the givers of my food and my drink, my wool and my linen, my oil and my refreshment." Only, patience! patience! "I see it, but not now; I behold it, but not nigh," — the further word of the prophet also (Hos. 2. 7 ff.) will one day find its confirmation: "Behold, I hedge up thy way with thorns, and fence it in with a wall, that thou shalt not find her paths. And she shall run after her lovers and shall not overtake them, she shall seek them and shall not find them; and then she shall say: "I will go and return to my first husband, for then had I it better than now.'" O, the prophet understood his people, if only they would understand him too.
The chief argument which Dr. L. brings into the field runs as follows: "For our religion set out upon its victorious march through the world from Sinai; the flaming Sinai and not the clod of Canaan is the birthplace of Judaism." A more unfortunate ground for his attacks he could not possibly have chosen The revelation of Sinai rests upon the firm and unshakable foundation of that one single utterance: "But ye, if ye will obey my voice and keep my covenant, then shall ye be a peculiar treasure unto me above all nations, for all the earth is mine. And ye shall be unto me a kingdom of priests and a holy people." A nation, a kingdom, a people!
Israel a nation, a kingdom, a people — that is a fundamental proposition of just such inviolable validity as the utterance: "I am the Lord thy God." The united people of Israel is the bearer of the united consciousness of God.
Their nationhood these men have abandoned and forgotten, and so much the more do they emphasise their religion, which, if popular report may be believed, is said to be yet more indifferent to them. Thus our hero too exclaims with emphasis: "But what is the Jewish religion to the Zionists!" Gently, my friend — do but look at them once, these Zionists in Germany, Austria, Russia, England and America. One might almost suppose that they esteem their Jewish religion quite as highly as Herr Leimdörfer and his fellows. Does Herr Leimdörfer perhaps know the poet's saying concerning science:
To one she is the exalted, the heavenly goddess; to another A serviceable cow, that supplies him with butter.
I believe that, if one were to apply the saying to the present case and to draw a comparison, the better half of the couplet would assuredly fall to the Zionists.
Zionism — for my own part I much prefer to say the consciousness of nationality, the Jewish-national idea, the feeling of stock and people — is supposed to have injured the faith and its confessors in the eyes of the world. I am of the contrary opinion and conviction. It has done the faith no injury, for it took its origin from the very midst of an earnest and enthusiastic faith, and so much is certain, that these so-called Zionists possess ten times more piety of disposition and Jewish-religious fidelity to the Law than do their opponents.
And Zionism has brought forth wonders — the history of religion has many wonders to record, such a one as this perhaps not yet. I have met among the German-Jewish youth, and especially among the students, pupils, sons whose parents had already grown wholly estranged from Judaism, even sons of university men (physicians, jurists) — what that signifies, the initiated will know how to appreciate — who had become zealous believers and law-abiding Jews once more: this Zionism had wrought. And this Zionism is supposed to be to the detriment of religion! —
Nor can Zionism assuredly have done us harm among the confessors of other religions and the members of other nations. I have had the feeling from my youth up, that a living, purposeful and self-confident sense of stock and