No. 9. — "Die Welt" — Page 9.
Tribune.
(In this place we gladly give room to communications which, in a becoming tone, treat of matters of general interest or of well-founded complaints. The Editors.)
Health Resorts in Palestine.
An eminent and gratifying factor in the questions of the colonisation and civilisation of Palestine is offered by its delicious climate and by the presence of numerous thermal springs. This knowledge, already turned to account in antiquity, is of particular value for our own age, and the question ought to be pursued further, in the interest of humanity as well. These seats of ancient civilisation lie to-day weathered and laid waste, the consequence of two thousand years of destructive warfare. In our ingenious and enterprising age the impulse need only be given from some quarter possessed of capital, and there may arise an Eldorado for those in need of healing: climatic resorts for sufferers from affections of the heart, the lungs and the nerves, upon the coast and upon the mountain plateaus. An uncommonly rich field for exploitation is offered by the multitude of iodine, sulphur, bromine and acidulous springs.
For the present let a beginning be made with a single larger establishment, a handsome pleasure resort by the sea, and indeed in the neighbourhood of Jaffa, perhaps to the south below the lighthouse, near the baths, among magnificent gardens of pine, olive, orange and palm. Such a resort would of course have to be furnished with every modern comfort.
Favourable to this site is the nearness of a junction of the world's traffic, the point of entry into the interior of the country, the only railway to Jerusalem, the use of all European languages, and — last not least — the rapid and reliable communications with all countries for the swift procuring of every kind of produce. Once the land has been properly explored and a wider local traffic made possible by means of communication, then one may proceed further along this road. Josef Stephan Oster.
Prize Competition.
On the part of a friend of Jewish poetry, who does not wish to be named, the sum of 500 frcs. has been designated as a prize for the best text of a Jewish national hymn.
Poems in all languages are admitted to the competition. Provision will be made for the translation of the prize-crowned text into Hebrew and into other idioms current among Jews; the music to the text is to be obtained by way of a further prize competition.
The office of judges has been kindly undertaken by: Messrs. Dr. N. Birnbaum, Dr. M. Ehrenpreis, Dr. Theodor Herzl, Dr. S. R. Landau, Dr. Max Nordau. From Dr. Gaster and two other gentlemen, who were likewise requested, the answers are still awaited.
The closing date for the receipt of contributions has, upon requests from many quarters, been extended to the 15th of September 1897. Address: Editors of the "Zion," Berlin N. W., Lessingstrasse 23.
The poems sent in should be marked not with the name or a pseudonym, but with a motto, the name being given in a sealed envelope bearing that motto as its superscription.
Editors of the "Zion" Monthly Review for the National Interests of the Jewish People.
Are the Jews a Race?
Whoever would not be misunderstood on any side must, before he answers the question whether the Jews are a race, say what he understands by race. If the word race be taken in the sense that it denotes a body of men who are related to one another by the bond of common descent and who contain no foreign ethnic constituents, then the Jews are no race — then indeed one may not speak of any race at all to-day. — Since our endeavours to nationalise the Jews can be neither materially furthered by the assertion that the Jews are a pure and unmixed race, nor in the least injured by the contrary assertion, that the Semitic element properly forms but a small minority among the Jews of to-day, we shall attempt to render in an objective manner the present state of this difficult question.
In the course of our exposition we shall refer chiefly to a lecture by Dr. Alsberg: "Die Racenmischung im Judenthum." He began with the following words: Until lately the purity of the Jewish race was an almost undisputed dogma; for not only in lay circles but among anthropologists as well the opinion was fairly generally current that the children of Israel had preserved the Semitic type represented by them free from admixture with other ethnic elements, and that, by virtue of an isolation and seclusion continued through thousands of years, they had maintained this purity of stock down to the present day. In opposition to this he now advances the assertion that the Jews, already thousands of years ago in Palestine and Hither Asia, entered into a mixture with Indo-Germanic elements and probably also with members of the Mongolian race. Since the author lays the chief weight of his demonstration upon an intermixture with Indo-Germans, we shall occupy ourselves only with this part of his assertions. The principal proof consists in this, that upon representations in Egyptian tombs from the time of Rameses II. the Amana and Schaju of Tanaan, who dwelt in Palestine before the Jews, are depicted with reddish-blond hair, a beard of the same colour, and blue eyes. With this it is connected that blond, blue-eyed Jews are met with in the most remote regions of the world, in North Africa, Portugal and Russia as well as in Asia Minor and Persia.
If we would not skip superficially over the problem whether an intermixture with Aryans is here actually present, we must draw the question of the descent of man into the discussion.
Since the popularisation of Darwin's works even the least educated knows that men are not descended from Adam and Eve, but have developed out of lower creatures; and much speaks for the view that this development did not proceed at a single point alone from one high-standing animal type, but plainly took place in the course of time at various points of the earth's surface many times over. (Gumplowicz: Racenkämpfe).
In this case one does not assume that, for example, blond and blue-eyed men developed only once somewhere, let us say in the ancestral stock of the Aryans, but holds it to be plausible that the blond type of humanity emerged independently at various times.
In view of this assumption it would be difficult in any case for the author of the lecture mentioned to prove the membership of the aboriginal inhabitants of Palestine in a particular race by the bare argument: "Blond, blue eyes."
It must, however, appear one-sided if intermixture with other races be regarded as the sole factor differentiating a race. Variability through external influences is operative in man also. The Jews, living under other climatic conditions, took on in the course of time other somatic qualities, and the variability of the Jewish race modified the original type in consequence of the altered climatic conditions.
The Jewish people too will doubtless have mixed with foreign ethnic elements in the course of its history, which, in view of the high gifts the Jews have ever displayed, is probable a priori. For according to a proposition acknowledged by all ethnologists it is precisely the lowest peoples, those commonly designated as savages, that have preserved the greatest purity of stock. Only, to cite a word of Andree's, our seemingly indestructible stock has "wholly overcome and so absorbed all admixtures that the general homogeneous fabric did not suffer thereby." We must further take into consideration that at all times the lawgivers and teachers sought to preserve the Jews from intermixture with other peoples, that they might not exchange their divine worship for an idolatry. The word of Tacitus also: alienarum concubitu Judali