Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 6 · 9 July 1897
7printed page
scan 11 of 20

No. 6. — "Die Welt" — Page 7.

(continued from page 6)

The Congress.

…resolutions manufactured and adopted by the gentlemen in question are therefore to be regarded merely as the private opinion of a few people, and they are treated as such.

The gentlemen play an all the more pitiable part in the struggle against Zionism, since they are in no position to advance any sound reasons whatever for their attitude. The be-all and end-all of their arguments is, by their own admission, the fear that the movement might be misinterpreted and cast the shadow of a doubt upon the civic virtues and the patriotism of the Jews.

This timorous fretting exposes those gentlemen to ridicule all the more, since in the near future the Jewish people proper, the humbler mass, intends to convene meetings in order to lodge a protest against such an interpretation of the Zionist movement.

Last Sunday the society "Chowewe Zion", composed for the most part of Jews immigrated from Russia, held an exceedingly interesting meeting, to which the undersigned was fetched by a deputation in order to furnish some explanations. At this meeting the resolutions of the reverend rabbis were thoroughly raked over and their proceeding protested against. Thereupon the several points drawn up for the Congress were deliberated one by one, and the members took up their position with regard to them. Finally it was resolved to send two delegates to the Congress and, until the Congress, to arrange mass meetings especially in Russian-Jewish circles.

The "Zion-Association" existing in Baltimore is now developing, at our instance, a praiseworthy activity in the State of Maryland, and it is to be expected that in the said State several Zion societies will shortly come into being. The Association there is sending a delegate to the Congress.

A few days ago a deputation of the academic youth of this city called upon me to announce the founding of the academic Zion society "Frei-Judah". The young men are full of enthusiasm and have resolved to arrange lecture evenings in the interest of the movement. The first lecture will be delivered by your correspondent.

Our society, the "Central Association of American Zionists", which called the movement in the United States into being, works untiringly and with a clear purpose. Since the mass meeting held on the 7th of June, upon the course of which I reported at length, we have had two further meetings, at which a considerable number of new members was gained.

Our endeavour is, to be sure, made harder by the fact that certain wealthy Jews not only hold aloof from the movement, but in many cases even seek to place it in a false light. There grows out of this a twofold task for us: on the one hand to strengthen the movement, and on the other to combat the infamies set in circulation. Still, hostility is more welcome to us than a cold indifference. For with the hostilities, which heighten the courage for battle, the number of our friends also grows, and already we have men in our midst in whose hearts the flames of true enthusiasm blaze.

And I believe I may prophesy with some assurance that in spite of, or perhaps precisely in consequence of, the manifold hostilities, it will be the Jews of the United States who will help the Zion idea to victory. Here, where everything grasps after authority, there will soon attach themselves to us — once our movement has survived its childhood ailments and proved its vitality — even such men as appear at most only where success is nearly assured, but who then, by their adherence, make the prospect of success perfectly certain.


The news of the removal of the Congress to Basle is being received very sympathetically in the circles of the participants. The preparatory commission receives numerous letters in which the choice of the present place of the Congress is described as a very happy one. To the Russian visitors to the Congress in particular Basle is very welcome, since against the choice of Zurich there would after all have been many a misgiving.

* * *

Of the disloyalty of some of our Jewish opponents, the manner in which the removal of the Zionist Congress to Basle is reported — or rather kept silent about — furnishes fine proofs. Thus one writes: "The Zionist Congress in Munich will not take place, because it has been condemned in the sharpest terms by the authoritative circles." — Basta! Whoever reads this must deeply pity the poor Zionists, condemned in the sharpest terms, who are now lamenting over their frustrated Congress. That the Congress has simply been transferred to Basle — of that this ingeniously drafted slip says not a word. "The Congress will not take place in Munich" and "The Congress in Munich will not take place" — that is a mighty difference. The author of this pretty distortion has talent. In time he may yet become a forger of consequence.

* * *

The Jewish weekly "The Jewish Exponent" of Philadelphia, which has just come to hand, devotes the greater part of this number to "Zionism and the Congress". Seven of the most eminent rabbis and scholars of North America were questioned by the editors upon this theme, and we find their views, laid down in detailed articles, reproduced. Of those questioned, five have declared themselves for Zionism and two against it. So quickly had the "Preß" canard about the "circles without influence" to fall into the water. One sees which current of the times now "influences" the Jewish authorities the more.

In the brief reproduction of the inquiry upon Zionism we will give precedence to our opponents. They are not unwelcome to us. Long may such opponents be preserved to us. Rabbi Levy and Dr. S. Morais move along well-trodden paths. Since they still always prefer the lesser evil, they have of course "nothing to urge against a colonisation of poor Jews". A rabbi gets nothing from these in any case. Only not, God forbid, a Jewish State. "For Zion is a symbol, and Zionism is a — bomb beneath the hopes of Israel" — so opined the anxious Rabbi I. Leonard Levy. He has, moreover, despite several years' study of Holy Writ, found no passage which would refer to a return of the Jews to Palestine and which had not already been fulfilled by the return from Babylon that took place. And the "mission"? The two gentlemen feel thoroughly at their ease only when they begin to speak of it. Only they know nothing to say. "No Jew who believes in the 'universal mission' of his religion can seriously occupy himself with political Zionism?" Why? Aye, if only they knew that themselves!

But upon this they receive a trenchant answer from the Rev. Dr. Felsenthal of Chicago.

"The Jews are to fulfil a mission in the lands where they dwell. That is one of the hollow phrases one hears so often. The Jews in Kishineff, the Jews in Teheran, the Jews in Yemen have a mission to fulfil — in Kishineff, in Teheran, in Yemen! There are few words so falsely interpreted as the words 'mission of Judaism', and so often used, or rather misused, by loud-mouthed speakers and writers."

And to the objection of the hurrah-patriots he replies:

"Is it unpatriotic to leave our birthplace and to become subjects of another State? That is surely a hollow phrase. Have our friends, Rabbi X., Dr. Y.,