— 13 —
Has the directorate of the JCA, then, asked itself why these experiments, so promising and so important for the further settlement of the country, do not succeed? Consider the situation of a tenant of the JCA. The labourer receives an area for cultivation, often measured far too generously (we are not of the opinion that "only" 12 ha of land are insufficient), for one year. The money advanced to him, some 1500 Francs, he is bound to pay back out of the next year's harvest. Buildings are not placed at his disposal, or only in insufficient measure: at Athlit the tenants dispose of one wooden barrack (there are now two of them), in which the working cattle are housed and in which the people must live as well; at Betdschen the tenants inhabit the half-ruined primitive Arab huts of the village, have no stables and granaries, and — what for a husbandman is among the chief things — both at Athlit and at Betdschen they were not in possession of yards and vegetable gardens, which would give them the possibility of raising poultry and producing milk and vegetables. It is an old maxim of the husbandman's experience that the profit must consist less in the penny earned than in the penny saved. And here the tenants had to buy everything they needed for their subsistence. They have never been able to have the feeling of a home of their own. The whole bore the character of the "preliminary," the provisional. Indeed, if the tenants, instead of being provisionally installed, had received the land ceded to them for cultivation not for one year but for at least 5–7 years — even if only 12–15 ha — they would work it with quite another diligence. The tenants are said, it is true, to take honest pains even now, but the utilization of the land is after all only an extensive one; a clearing, better working, manuring can never pay for itself in one year, nor yet in 2–3 years. If the diligence of the tenants is emphasized with praise, it must nevertheless be said here that their performances are significant only quantitatively, not qualitatively — which indeed cannot reasonably be demanded of them either. Had the tenants a small farmstead, however modest, with house, stable, granary, and vegetable garden, they could from the very beginning at least cover their need of foodstuffs from their own husbandry. Later they would also gradually be able to attain a relative prosperity.