— 324 —
co-operated, since such enterprises are notoriously "out-of-house undertakings," which employ their workers at numerous different places.
* * *
Nowhere, however, has profit-sharing proved itself so superior to the wage system as a constitution of labour as in agriculture. I shall at the close briefly present some of the existing experiments and experiences: here let it first be shown why this favourable result could, nay must, be expected.
First of all one must make clear to oneself that the entrepreneur of large-scale agriculture finds himself in a much less favourable position toward his workers than his fellow in large-scale industry. For on the land the workers are just as scarce as they are present in superabundance on the industrial labour markets: the effect of the "migration" from the flat country into the towns! In consequence the estate-owner, through the counter-service of the wage, gets out of his workers a relatively far smaller performance in strength and care than does the great industrialist. For the latter can dismiss a "hand" of under-average performance at any moment, certain of being able at once to fill the place several times over with average forces, while the great agriculturist must keep even the poorer worker as long as possible, because it is extremely uncertain whether he will be able to find a better one — indeed, whether he will be able to find any substitute at all. One might almost say that the industrial worker, despite his seemingly freer social position, stands much nearer to the slave: for his master swings over him the threatening whip of dismissal, of unemployment, and of economic ruin, whereas for the agricultural labourer this threat remains under present conditions a purely academic one, which leaves no impression whatever. At the worst, even the agricultural labourer without a place lives — on the poor-relief of the parish, with a little casual work, which is always to be found for him, and a little pilfering of wood and field — not so very much worse than when he is in service.
Under these circumstances the pure wage system in German large-scale agriculture has indeed already as good as completely played itself out; the outcry of the Agrarians over the