199
…(egoistic power stops the mouths of those who think). The theoretical struggle cannot accomplish the victory, and the sacred power of thought succumbs to the force of egoism. Only the egoistic struggle, the struggle of egoists on both sides, brings everything to clearness.
This last, now — to make thinking itself a matter of egoistic pleasure, a matter of the unique one, as it were a mere pastime or hobby, and to take from it the significance of "being the last decisive power"; this degradation and desecration of thinking, this equalisation of the thoughtless and the thoughtful I, this clumsy but real "equality" — criticism is unable to bring about, because it is itself only the priestess of thinking, and beyond thinking sees nothing but — the deluge.
Criticism does indeed assert, for example, that free criticism may be victorious over the State; but at the same time it defends itself against the reproach made against it by the government, that it is "wilfulness and insolence"; it thinks, then, that "wilfulness and insolence" may not be victorious, only it may. The truth is rather the reverse: the State can be really vanquished only by insolent wilfulness.
It may now, to conclude with this, be evident that the critic in his new turn has not transformed himself, but has only "made good an oversight," has "come to a clear understanding with an object," and says too much when he speaks of "criticism criticising itself"; it, or rather he, has only criticised its "oversight" and purged it of its "inconsistencies." Had he wished to criticise criticism, he must have looked to see whether there was anything in its presupposition.