Additions to the Essay on Holy Things 43
…Maimonides (chapter 6 of the Laws of the Chosen House), and Rabad did not object against him. If so, Ezra did not sanctify the House at all, but only relied on Solomon, who sanctified it for the future. And a further difficulty: if Solomon did not sanctify it for the future, by what was it sanctified in the days of Ezra, since "with all these" we learned? — And it seems that Rabad did not write so as the law, but only according to Rabbi Yose, because the contradiction of Rabbi Yose against Rabbi Yose was difficult for him: for in Seder Olam, "a third they do not have", that the second was not annulled; and in Zevahim it is written, "Ravina said: in truth he holds it was not sanctified", according to the reading of Rashi there. Therefore he distinguishes for Rabbi Yose, that the holiness of the rest of the Land of Israel was sanctified for the future, and the holiness of the Sanctuary was not sanctified. But in truth, for us, who hold as Rabbi Yohanan, who holds that one who offers up in this time is liable, because it was sanctified with the holiness of the House. End of his words. Behold, I came close to the view of the Gaon mentioned above, for according to my way which I wrote there all the difficulties mentioned above are resolved.
- As to the essential law, that it was sanctified for the future: all the decisors hold as Maimonides — the Tashbetz, and the Maharit, and our master Rabbi Hayyim of Paris, and the Responsa of Yaavetz, and the Responsa Hatam Sofer, and the Responsa of Maharin; and likewise the Sefer ha-Terumah, cited in the Kaftor va-Ferah; and likewise the Magen Avraham (in section 561) ruled as Maimonides; and likewise in the Yaarot Devash he brought many proofs for the ruling of Maimonides. And the Gaon, head of the rabbinical court of Grätz, wrote that it is certainly proper to rule as Maimonides, for the chief difficulty of Rabad is from that of "they shall rot"; and behold, the Mishneh le-Melekh and the Tashbetz answered his difficulty, that there it compares second tithe to the firstborn; see there. And on this the Rabbi, our teacher Rabbi Hayyim Mordekhai mentioned above, brought me another sound answer from the book Korban Hagigah by the Gaon Galante, at the end of the book of the Gaon our teacher Rabbi Moses Hagiz, which answered that "if there is no Temple, they shall rot" means at a time when there are no ashes of the Heifer (for second tithe is not eaten in impurity); and that we offer sacrifices is found in the case of community sacrifices, which do not require the ashes of the Heifer. And the Gaon mentioned above answered further according to the words of Tosafot, that a built altar is required; and according to this, what Maimonides wrote, that one eats holy things and second tithe even though there is no wall, means when the altar is built; and what is said, "they shall rot", means when we have no altar, as in our time. And with this he explains several verses in Psalms properly; see there*).
*) Note. In Ha-Levanon, page 74, in my dialectics with the great luminary, our teacher Rabbi D. P. of Mohilev mentioned above, I wrote further: besides that all the decisors hold as Maimonides, according to our words Rabad too holds as Maimonides. And I added that even should Rabad hold that it was not sanctified, nevertheless perhaps Rabad holds as Rashi and not as Rabbi Hayyim, that if so even the high places are permitted, all the more so with a built altar in the holy place; and if so we have no clear dissenter on the essential view of Maimonides, that one offers sacrifices in this time. And I wrote further there a proof that Rabad does not hold as Rabbi Hayyim in the matter of the high places: for it is difficult for the one who says it was not sanctified — if so, they would have had to sanctify the Court in the days of Ezra; and behold, we say (in Shevuot 15): "The Court is sanctified only with the remnants of the meal-offering"; and how did they have remnants of the meal-offering? For the taking of the handful and the burning require the Court, and the Court was not yet sanctified. Necessarily, the one who says it was not sanctified holds that it is permitted on a high place, and they had remnants of the meal-offering from a high place. And Tosafot raised a difficulty like this according to the one who says there is no meal-offering on a high place; but according to the one who says there is a meal-offering on a high place it is not difficult for them. If so, it is proven that Tosafot hold not as Rabbi Hayyim, for they had remnants of the meal-offering from a high place; and as for Rabbi Hayyim himself, it may be said that he holds it was sanctified for the future. But Rabad, if he holds as the law that it was not sanctified, how is the holiness of the Court found from Ezra on? Necessarily, the high places are permitted.
11