Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion, Jerusalem Edition · 1919
56scan
of 139

Essay on Holy Things

…concerning a rabbinic law is resolved leniently; and moreover it is a double doubt: a doubt whether she was defiled, a doubt whether he is not a priest." End of quotation. And in my poor and feeble opinion, this much is correct to draw from the words of Rivash, that they are priests by doubt; but in what Rashdam wrote, that being called first to the Torah is nothing but mere custom, and as he also wrote, "it is enough for us to be strict in what is a certain prohibition", the implication is that this too is only by way of stringency; and in my humble opinion, begging the pardon of his honour's learning, it is not so, since in any case they are in the presumption of priests, they do not leave the realm of doubt, and they are forbidden by law in the prohibitions of the priesthood as certain priests. And likewise it is by way of obligation to call them first, out of the doubt that they may be priests, and we are obliged to fulfil with them the positive commandment "And thou shalt sanctify him". And what Rivash wrote, "it became the custom", means that it became the custom according to the law; for they go up to the lifting of the hands, where one cannot speak of mere stringency, since if they are not priests they transgress a positive commandment (see Magen Avraham, beginning of section 128). And in the Responsa Hut ha-Shani, section 40, he wrote, and these are his words: "And we learn in the chapter Ha-Ishah Rabbah: whence do we know that if he did not wish, we compel him? Scripture says, 'And thou shalt sanctify him'. And there is no distinction in this between the earlier ones, who had a written record of lineage, except in the matter of permitting them a thing that is forbidden to non-priests; but in the matter of forbidding them anything that is forbidden to priests there is no distinction." End of quotation. And this is not in accordance with Rashdam mentioned above. And nevertheless this is only so as not to permit them anything that is forbidden to priests; but nevertheless, as to permitting them anything that is forbidden to non-priests, there is a distinction between the earlier generations and the priests of our time, inasmuch as in truth, in my humble opinion, it stands to reason that one must not be lenient with them in any matter of the rabbinic disqualifications of the priesthood, since they have been presumed to be priests. And indeed Rivash himself wrote (in section 348) to forbid to a priest a woman divorced by rabbinic law, and the implication is that this holds for the priests of our time; but nevertheless one may say, according to the opinion of Hut ha-Shani, that we are strict so as not to permit them a thing that is forbidden to non-priests. And as to their lifting their hands, one must say that since they have been presumed, for this they have been presumed; or else, since in the reverse case too, by neglecting the lifting of the hands, they likewise transgress a positive commandment (except that nevertheless it would have been proper to rule not to call them to go up, and then there is no positive commandment). Maharit too, in his Responsa (section 149), rules throughout not to be lenient with them in anything that is forbidden to certain priests. Afterwards I found the matter exactly as it stands in the Rabbi, our teacher Rabbi Shmuel Yafeh, in his book Yefeh Mar'eh on the aggadot of the Jerusalem Talmud, who wrote on Berakhot (chapter 8, halakhah 2), at the passage beginning "Whoever makes use of the priesthood has committed sacrilege", and these are his words: "As to the fact that people are not careful about this now, one may judge them favourably, because there is now no priest of certainly attested lineage, and many of them are counterfeit, as Rivash wrote (section 94); but nevertheless no priest may be lenient in any prohibition of the priesthood, for since he holds himself to be a priest he must conduct himself by all the laws of the stringency of the priesthood, for we follow the presumption toward stringency. And I found it necessary to write this because I saw someone who wrote, drawing on the words of Rivash mentioned above, that one may be lenient with a priest in a rabbinic prohibition of the priesthood; and this is not so, for Rivash himself was strict (in section 348) even concerning rabbinic heave-offering for a priest of his days." End of quotation. Thus it is as we said, that one must not be lenient with them in any matter that is forbidden to a priest, for one follows the presumption toward stringency; nevertheless it is clear from the opinion of Maharash that, for leniency, to permit them what is forbidden to non-priests, we do not judge them as certain priests. And so wrote Maharin, cited in the gloss on the Shulhan Arukh, Orah Hayyim (section 457): "And some say that at this time one does not give the dough-offering to any priest to eat"; and so Rashal copied it as law in Yam shel Shlomo, beginning of chapter 5 of Hullin (section 4), for the reason that they now have no written record of lineage. And more strongly still, Rashal wrote in Yam shel Shlomo, chapter 5 of Bava Kamma (section