Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion, Jerusalem Edition · 1919
54scan
of 139

Essay on the Service

…made an enactment only where it is possible with men of attested lineage; but where it is impossible, there being no one of attested lineage here, would they uproot a Service of Torah law for the sake of a rabbinic higher standard? And although the Sages have power to uproot a positive commandment of the Torah for the sake of a decree, that is when it is occasional, as for instance not to blow the shofar on a New Year that falls on the Sabbath, where it is uprooted only in that year; but wherever the commandment would be uprooted for ever, no; and as the Magen Avraham wrote (section 589, subsection 4), see there. And if so, when the Service is possible, how should it be uprooted for the sake of a higher standard? And the obligation of the commandment of the Service is not removed from us; wherever there is permission and possibility to offer, the good is incumbent upon the whole community of Israel as of old.

A third reply: that Maimonides wrote explicitly in the Commentary on the Mishnah, Kiddushin, on our Mishnah "One who marries a priest's daughter must examine after her", and these are his words at the end of his remarks there: "And all this is obligatory with a family against which a challenge has been raised, that is, that they say that such-and-such a family has an unfit person in it; but a family in which there is no suspicion needs no examination, for the principle with us is that all families stand in the presumption of fitness." End of his words. And so the Rabbi wrote, chapter four of Kiddushin. And behold, concerning this examination we learned, "One does not examine from the altar upward," and these are the words of Maimonides in his Code above; hence all this is said only when a challenge has been raised against the family, but without a challenge no examination is needed, neither in the mothers nor in the altar; and this is clear.

And a further proof of the matter: for it is difficult regarding Maimonides, since it is known that lineage is more stringent than heave-offering, for they dispute in the Talmud whether one promotes from heave-offering to lineage; why then, in chapter 19, regarding the marriage of a priest's daughter, which is a matter of lineage, did he write that examination is needed only where a challenge has been raised, and here in chapter 20, regarding heave-offering, he wrote without qualification that one must be of attested lineage, which implies even without a challenge? Therefore it seems to be one of these two: either that in chapter 20, although he stated it without qualification, nevertheless he speaks of a case of challenge; or, what seems more likely, since there is a further difficulty, that he wrote there (halakhah 1): "Heave-offering of the Torah and dough-offering of the Torah are eaten only by a priest of attested lineage." End of his words. And it is difficult: in this time there is no heave-offering of Torah law and no dough-offering of Torah law, as Maimonides wrote there (halakhah 3); rather, Maimonides certainly speaks of the time of the Temple, while there was a flaw upon all the priests who had married foreign women in Babylon, as I brought above from the words of Rashi; but after they were truly made clean, there is no need to be of attested lineage from the altar, or of examination, for one relies on the presumption.

And by our way there is a further proof from the language of Maimonides (end of the Laws of Kings, chapter 12, halakhah 2), and these are his words: "Behold, I send Elijah; and he comes neither to declare impure the pure, nor to declare pure the impure, nor to disqualify men who are in the presumption of fitness, but to set peace in the world, etc." And in halakhah 3: "In the days of the King Messiah, etc., all of them will have their lineage traced by his word, through the holy spirit that will rest upon him, as it is said: And he shall sit as a refiner and purifier; and the sons of Levi he will purify first, etc. And he traces the lineage of Israel only to their tribes, making known that this one is of such-and-such a tribe; but he does not say of one who is in the presumption of fitness, this one is a bastard and this one a slave, for the law is that a family that has been assimilated stays assimilated." End of his words. And so it is in the Talmud (Kiddushin 71): "Rabbi Yohanan said: The Holy One, blessed be He, did a kindness with Israel, that a family that has been assimilated stays assimilated."

And perhaps you will say that all this is only for the future, when the true Messiah comes; then all will be purified,