Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion, Jerusalem Edition · 1919
27scan
of 139

Seeking — First Essay — Zion 14

…and the burnt-offering of the New Moon we shall offer up upon it"; and afterwards, "and in the Service of the Temple we shall all be glad": only an altar shall we prepare, and at the time of the Temple we shall all be glad; "we will rejoice and be glad in it."

  1. Yet another great proof I shall set before you for our way, the way of the Jerusalem Talmud: for we have learned in Eduyot (chapter 8, mishnah 7): "Rabbi Joshua said: I have received a tradition from Rabban Yohanan ben Zakkai, who heard it from his teacher, and his teacher from his teacher, a law given to Moses at Sinai, that Elijah does not come to declare impure or to declare pure, to put away or to bring near, but to bring near those put away by force, etc." And the Ra'av explained that he does not come to clarify the doubt of the families, who has become impure, but will leave them, and they are fit, etc. End of his words. And there is cause for wonder at this saying: is it then a halakhah for the Messiah? And why was a law given to Moses at Sinai needed for a matter that will be in the time to come? Surely, at the time when Elijah comes, and all his holy ones with him, will they not know then what to do? And we have no practical consequence at all in the law given to Moses at Sinai; only for Elijah is there a practical consequence, and he has no need of the law given to Moses at Sinai. And so we find in several places that the Talmud objects, "A halakhah for the Messiah?" But according to our way mentioned above there will be an enormous benefit in this halakhah. For when the beginning of the ingathering takes place without a prophet, and we are granted permission to offer sacrifices, and there is a built altar without a Sanctuary and without a prophet, and we do not know what we shall do for a sweet savour to Yahweh, because we wait for a prophet to make known to us the purity of the priests and their lineage; and when there is no sacrifice to atone, the light of prophecy will not shine forth, and if there is no prophecy to clarify a priest or to clarify this halakhah, there will be no sacrifice; and if so, the redemption would be something of an impossibility, for there is no sacrifice without Elijah and no Elijah without a sacrifice. Therefore He who is great in counsel and mighty in work made known to us beforehand, through a law given to Moses at Sinai, that we should not wait for Elijah in this matter; for he will not clarify the purity of the families, but will leave all the priests in the presumption of their fitness; and then we shall offer a sacrifice without apprehension lest the officiating priest be disqualified. And it will be, as the meal-offering goes up, that an angel of God will appear to them and do wondrously, and our eyes, like Manoah's, will see; and we shall be found worthy to behold the pleasantness of Yahweh, and the raising up of prophets as in the years of old; and then the completeness of the redemption will come, as we have learned: "and the holy spirit leads to the resurrection of the dead", speedily in our days. Amen.

  2. And so we find in the Hallel, with which praise is offered at all times, that in it are included all the hardships and all the turns of events from beginning to end. First he spoke of natural faith, and praises it, in saying, "Who is enthroned on high, who looks down low upon the heavens" (for to the exceeding loftiness of the Infinite, blessed be He, even to look upon the heavens He stoops very low in looking at them, for He is enthroned on high; and if so, He looks upon the earth too). Afterwards he spoke of miraculous faith, "When Israel went forth out of Egypt", and gives praise for it; and afterwards, "Not unto us, but unto Thy name give glory", and that is a prayer concerning the exile, for His great name is profaned among the nations; therefore "unto Thy name give glory". And over all of them he used the language of praise and thanksgiving, for the Hallel was instituted with regard to the end of all the deeds, when it will be known that the hardships and the judgments too will be only goodness and lovingkindness to Israel in their latter end (as I have explained this at length elsewhere). Afterwards he said, "Yahweh has remembered us", and that refers to the redemption of the Second Temple, that He remembered Israel with blessing, so that we might know that not the dead in the land of darkness shall praise Yah, but we, in the land of the living, in the Holy Land, shall praise Yah. Afterwards he said, "I love, because He hears my voice; the cords of death compassed me", and that is this bitter exile; and all of it in the language of praise; for He loves it when He hears the voice of Jacob out of the midst of the troubles, and it is more beloved to Him to bear troubles, that He may hear the voice of Jacob, than that he should know nothing at all of the sound of