Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion, Jerusalem Edition · 1919
19scan
of 139

The Gate of Zion 10

…Nahmanides and those who side with him, who hold that this counts as a positive commandment, nevertheless agree that it is not an obligatory commandment like other commandments; and it is explained in the Talmud there, "three oaths" etc., one, that they should not go up as a wall — and if so, it is certainly not an obligatory commandment upon each and every man; and if so, by what is her power greater to compel her husband to fulfil this commandment of dwelling in the Land, more than other obligatory commandments? They said: "A man has it in his power to do it; a woman has not it in her power to do it," and she cannot compel her husband to let her fulfil the commandment of honouring father and mother. End of his words.

How greatly I wonder at his words! Did not Nahmanides speak a clear word in his Book of the Commandments, in these words there: "If so, it is a positive commandment for all generations, binding every one of us, even in the time of the Exile, as is known from the Talmud in many places" etc.; and at its end he also brings there the Sifre, how the dwelling in the Land of Israel is equal to all the commandments in the Torah. End of the words of Nahmanides. In his holy language he said "binding every one of us" etc., and "equal to all the commandments in the Torah", which are obligatory; and where, then, is the place where the Gaon mentioned above found that Nahmanides and those who side with him agree that it is not an obligatory commandment like the other commandments? Also what he explains from the Talmud there, "three oaths, one, that they should not go up as a wall, and if so it is certainly not an obligatory commandment" etc. — he did not examine it closely enough, with all respect to his honour, for Rashi explained, in these words: "As a wall: together, with a strong hand." So it is: we are sworn and bound not to rebel against the kingdoms while we dwell in the Exile — "in their assembly let our glory not be united" — and there is also an oath not to rebel against the kingdoms by going up together with a strong hand; but when there shall be permission from the kingdoms, it is a duty upon all of us to go; and this is the rebellion and the trespass from which our fathers did not cleanse themselves in the Second Temple — this brought about the Exile for us too, and the destruction (and see my work Kol Tzofayikh in Sedeh Tzofim, and in the second gate, Sollu ha-Mesillah). Also the end of his words, "and is not honouring father and mother an obligatory commandment" etc., is a wonder too lofty for me, I cannot attain to it: for there the obligation to honour her father does not lie upon him by the Torah, but only upon her; therefore she cannot compel the husband etc.; but in dwelling in the Land the obligation upon both of them is equal, for it is an obligatory commandment upon each and every one.

Thus far the words of the one who brought this to press.

Also the Rabbi, the editor of Ha-Maggid, gave his full support to the men of Shabatz mentioned above in the note to the Opening, who say that many seek to till the soil, the holy soil; and these are the words of the editor of Ha-Maggid there, number 32, year 9.

Note of the publisher: We have printed the letter mentioned above so that it may be known that there are many who desire to go up to the Holy Land to till its soil and to be satisfied with its goodness, and not only to live a life of sloth and idleness; for I know those honoured men, the writers, whose whole aim is to eat of the labour of their hands and by the sweat of their brow; only the place is too narrow for them in their native land, where the waters have come in even unto the soul, and their strength to bear has failed under the troubles which the government and the inhabitants of the country inflict upon them, so that their very lives hang in doubt before them. From this too it may be seen how great was the benefit that could have sprung from the Society for the Settlement of the Land of Israel, had there been unity in this matter, and had the bundle not come apart, for our many sins, etc.