Mount Tzvi 59
…nevertheless the chambers built upon it must be both built in holy ground and opening into holy ground, for only with these two are they holy for everything; and if one of them is lacking, then its interior and its space follow its opening. And it follows that the same is true of tunnels: granted that in the Court the tunnels too were sanctified, yet we require that its interior be aligned opposite the holy ground and also that it open into the holy; then it is sanctified for everything, like the Court itself. And now the matter is clear: those chambers of which the Mishnah of Ma'aser Sheni speaks, which were not sanctified for everything but only as regards eating, that is because there they are built in unconsecrated ground, and an opening into the hole avails only for eating; but a tunnel built in holy ground and opening into the holy was certainly sanctified for everything. And if so, the Tzelah rightly derives that upper chambers are no worse than tunnels, and they are compared one to the other: that if they are built in holy ground and open into the holy, they were sanctified for everything; and there is no room for the difficulty of the Minhat Hinukh at all. And it is all the more astonishing that he himself draws this distinction regarding tunnels, and regarding upper chambers did not come down to draw the same distinction. And likewise one may reject by this his answer to the difficulty of the Tzelah: for what is the objection in the Talmud there in Pesahim against the one who says roofs and upper chambers were not sanctified, from what we learned there, "The windows and the thickness of the wall are as within"? Surely one may say that the thickness of the wall is different, for they open into the holy, and therefore they are as within. And the Minhat Hinukh answers that an opening does not avail for everything. But according to what is mentioned above one may strengthen the difficulty of the Tzelah: upper chambers opening into the holy were sanctified entirely if they are aligned opposite the holy; and here too, surely the windows below were sanctified; if so, the thickness of the wall too was sanctified entirely, for it is like what is built in holy ground and opens into the holy. And likewise there is no room for his second answer, that the thickness of the wall is different because it opens both this way and that, and the opening does not avail; for this is not so, since it is explained in the Mishnah that there, in those opening both this way and that, what is opposite the holy is holy; and as for the thickness of the wall, we have already said that it counts as opposite the holy.
And in the book Be'er Sheva, on Tamid 27b, he expresses astonishment there at Rashi and Tosafot (Pesahim 66b), see there. Now his difficulty against Rashi has already been answered by Maharsha (page 86a): that Rashi, in the chapter Eilu Devarim, speaks according to the initial supposition, that Rabbi Yohanan speaks of the Court too. And in my humble opinion one may say that even according to the conclusion Rabbi Yohanan speaks of the Court too, and of such a case where they open not into the Court but only into the Temple Mount, and therefore they were not sanctified with the sanctity of the Court. And as to his second difficulty against Rashi, why he mentions the sanctity of the Court when they were not sanctified at all, it seems that one may say, according to what we say (Pesahim 86), "But the thickness of the wall, how can it be found? And he answers, it is found in the case of the bar shura"; and Rashi explained, "a small wall within the great wall, and it is low and level with the ground at the height of the Court, for the ground of the Court keeps rising and goes up by steps": it appears from this that as regards the sanctity of the pavement of the Court we measure by the highest place in the pavement, and against it we measure, to say that the sanctity extended also over the thickness of the wall; for although the thickness of the wall has the law of roofs, nevertheless, since it is level with the highest place in the pavement of the Court, it was then sanctified as part of the pavement. According to this, we too may say regarding tunnels: although in general they were not sanctified, nevertheless if the floor and the ground of the tunnel are level with the lowest place in the pavement of the Court, or with the ground of the Temple Mount, then the tunnel too was sanctified with the sanctity of the surface to which it is level. And therefore the tunnels of the Court which open into the Temple Mount, although with respect to the Court they are counted in the category of a tunnel, nevertheless it is possible that they lie on a surface level with the Temple Mount, as Rashi wrote, that the ground of the Court keeps rising and going up; and they were rightly sanctified with the sanctity of the Temple Mount, since with respect to
15