Mount Tzvi
52
…and did not object above (chapter 2, halakhah 4), where Maimonides wrote, "We offer sacrifices even though there is no House", since on the strength of this it is proved in Megillah and in other places that this master holds that the first sanctification sanctified for the time to come; and if so, according to Rabad, who holds that the sanctity was annulled, it must be that we do not offer sacrifices without a House. And at first glance there is room to say that this law, that we offer sacrifices even though there is no House, in truth holds even according to the one who says it did not sanctify for the time to come; and even according to him there is a practical difference in this halakhah, as regards the case where the House fell of itself after it had already been sanctified, or where they demolished it in order to build it again, as was done in the days of Herod. For it certainly stands to reason that in such a case annulment of sanctity does not apply at all, for that is said only when it was destroyed through conquest in war, "and nations came into thine inheritance", by way of demolition and destruction, since from the outset it was sanctified only for that time in which it is in our possession; but certainly when we demolish it of our own will, and this demolition is part of the building, and the place has not left our possession, there is in this no annulment of sanctity at all. And according to this, the novelty of this law, that we offer sacrifices even though there is no House *), has a practical consequence for all opinions, even for the one who says it did not sanctify for the time to come. And as for what is proved in Megillah and in other places, that the law of Rabbi Joshua, that we offer sacrifices even though there is no House, depends on the law that the first sanctity was not annulled: that is because Rabbi Joshua speaks of that time when they came up from Babylon, and the House had not yet been built since the day of the conquest and the first destruction; then it was certainly impossible to offer sacrifices without a House, unless we say that the first sanctity was not annulled; but according to the one who says it was annulled, it was then impossible to sanctify without a built House, as we say (Shevuot 15b), we require sanctification specifically at the time of building. And so the reason that the first sanctity was not annulled was rightly needed for their having offered sacrifices there without a House.
And plainly it seems that for this reason Rabad did not object in that passage of chapter 2 and waited until here, because it is one and the same: for here he uproots it, and above as well he relies on his objection made here. And as to what we say, that there is sanctification only at the time of building, we have some reflections on this from what we say (Zevahim 24a), "When David sanctified, it was the upper pavement that he sanctified", etc., from which it is plain that David sanctified the pavement of the Court with the sanctity of the Sanctuary. And why? Surely there is sanctification only at the time of building, and the House was not built until Solomon! Further, it is difficult for me that Maimonides (chapter 6 of the Laws of
*) At first it was difficult for me, concerning this law that we offer sacrifices even though there is no House: surely we say (Yoma 62b) that peace-offerings which were slaughtered before the doors of the Sanctuary were opened are unfit, as it is said, "And he shall slaughter it at the door of the Tent of Meeting"; and see Tosafot (Zevahim 68a), who disagree with Rashi and hold that this is not said of peace-offerings alone, but the same applies to all the sacrifices. And if so, when there is no House at all, why should it be better than before the doors of the Sanctuary were opened? But one is compelled to say that, according to the one who says it sanctified for the time to come, it is indeed regarded as though the Sanctuary were built, and we apply to it "the door of the Tent of Meeting". And afterwards I found that a great man of our generation wrote so. And at first glance the language of Rashi (Megillah 10a) proves so, who wrote on Rabbi Eliezer, who says, "I heard that when they were building in the Sanctuary they made curtains", and Rashi explained, "so that the altar built in the Court be called 'which is at the door of the Tent of Meeting'"; and the implication is that for Rabbi Joshua, who does not require curtains, the reason we offer sacrifices even though there is no House is that he rightly regards it as "the door of the Tent of Meeting" even without a House. But according to this, what we say (Zevahim 40a) requires study: "that if the roof of the Sanctuary was breached, he would not sprinkle"; and Rashi wrote, and these are his words, "the ceiling of its upper storey and its roof were breached; then it is no longer a tent". And why should it be worse than that case where we offer sacrifices even though there is no House at all, according to the one who says it sanctified for the time to come? Evidently, according to the one who says the sanctity of the Sanctuary was not annulled, it is regarded as "the door of the Tent of Meeting" even though there are neither partitions nor roof. And if there is no tent here, how is it called "the door of the Tent of Meeting"? And why do we offer sacrifices even though there is no House? And likewise on page 118a Rashi brings the exposition below, "priest", "the door of the Tent of Meeting", and there is no priest at a high place. And if so, in a place where we do not apply "the door of the Tent of Meeting", let us say that we do not require a priest, or that we do not offer sacrifices at all, since we require "the door of the Tent of Meeting" and it is lacking.