Essay on Holy Things 34
…exceedingly great, and why should a condition be needed in the matter? From this the Jerusalem Talmud says, "This implies that the building of the Sanctuary will be before there is the complete redemption of Messiah son of David, and then there will be the dominion of the nations over us"; and there will not yet be a court greater than there was in the days of the Tannaim; therefore a condition was needed. And so it is understood from the commentary of the Rabbi, the Tosafot Yom Tov, on the Jerusalem Talmud; see there. And since it is compelled by the Mishnah, our Talmud certainly does not disagree with the Jerusalem Talmud. And since it is established that the altar will first be built by human hands, the difficulty of Rashi and Tosafot remains in its place. Rashba too, in his novellae to Sukkah there, wrote on the difficulty of Rashi mentioned above: "And we have nothing to explain but as Rashi explained, etc."; see there. Thus he himself sensed that it is very forced, only that he did not know another explanation. And I, the least, who am dust beneath the soles of the feet of the great ones among the early authorities of blessed memory, have found, with Yahweh's help, after study, another explanation in the Talmud. And I would not lift up my head against these greatest of our masters, from whose waters alone we drink, to give an explanation other than that of Rashi and Tosafot, were it not that the Jerusalem Talmud mentioned above stands at my right hand. Therefore, O my lowly soul, tread on in strength in this, for the early authorities of blessed memory have left me room to distinguish myself in it. And it is this: that which we say, "There is no building of the Temple at night", we derive from "On the day that the Tabernacle was set up": by day one sets it up, and not by night; and from this it is derived there concerning an addition to the Courts, that it is not done at night. And if so, one may say that this holds for the Courts, which are in the place of the Tabernacle; but the vessels of the Tabernacle may be made at night, for the verse is precise only about the setting up of the Tabernacle; but the making of the particular parts and of the vessels for the needs of the Tabernacle, night was not excluded; for if it were not so, the Torah ought to have written the exclusion for all the work that they did then for the needs of the Tabernacle. Rather, it certainly excluded only the setting up of the Tabernacle itself, and not the vessels. And in the days of the Tabernacle the altar too was one of the vessels of the Tabernacle, and was not excluded by "On the day that the Tabernacle was set up"; and consequently for the generations too only the Courts and partitions, which resemble the Tabernacle, were excluded, but an altar it is permitted to build at night. And Tosafot wrote in our discussion in Sukkah, passage beginning "For last year": "And even according to Rabbi Joshua, who said that one offers sacrifice even though there is no House, that applies when the altar is built, but without an altar not, etc." And according to this the main thing depends on the building of the altar. And in Zevahim it is proved that in the Second House they first built the altar in order to offer sacrifice, and therefore they made hangings in place of the Courts, for modesty, in order to offer sacrifice before the building of the Courts was completed. And if so, in the future, when there will be permission to build an altar by human hands, according to the opinion of the Jerusalem Talmud and the Tosafot Yom Tov and Nahmanides, and the other proofs that I have brought, they will certainly first build an altar, in order to offer sacrifice all the days of the building, which must be many; or perhaps they will not build a House at all, but only "a new altar in Zion shalt thou establish", as the men of the Great Assembly arranged in the prayer of the New Moon. And the words of Rashi will also be fulfilled, that at the time when the Sanctuary comes complete, it will come from heaven, after our making of the altar, which is the preparation for all the perfection to come; therefore they arranged "in Zion shalt thou establish". And if so, this is what it says: "The Temple will speedily be built", and before it they will build an altar; and when the time for the Omer comes, when the altar is built at night (for the building of an altar may be done at night), then one will come to error, for at that time there will not yet be knowledge as the waters cover the sea. (And further, we find according to the method of Maimonides that an altar alone is also called a Sanctuary; for in chapter 6 of the Laws of the Chosen House Rabad objected to Maimonides, who distinguishes between the holiness of the Land of Israel and the holiness of the Sanctuary and the city, and objects from this: "If there is no Sanctuary, it shall rot"; and the Mishneh la-Melekh wrote there, halakhah 14, that Maimonides, and likewise the Tur, section 331, hold that it depends only on the altar, like the firstling, which cannot be eaten without an altar; see there. And according to this, that which we say, "If there is no