52
…cuts out, and which in the end amount to the emptiest nihilism and the most unbounded anarchy, which work only devastation in all Jewish hearts and estrange our younger generations more and more from Judaism.
One does the Reform, moreover, an undeserved honour in describing it as a free tendency of the mind in the higher sense. In a negative respect rationalistic criticism may indeed be described as a free tendency, since the negation of what has outlived itself is the first step to freedom. Positive freedom, however, is autonomous development, and the rationalistic Reform, which disowns the essence of Judaism, its nationality, cannot be creative, and therefore cannot be free in the higher sense. What it has achieved for the negative criticism of what is dead is, besides, precious little. For the most part, in this respect, we have to thank, as you rightly remarked, the conditions of a revolutionary age, for which the laggard rationalists, who pompously style themselves reformers, cannot be held responsible, in Judaism any more than in Christianity. — Modern society, which has issued from the Revolution, is a regenerated society, which is shaping itself autonomously; it does not reform and patch at the old, but creates something new. Every creation, however, rests upon something; out of nothing, nothing is created. — The national-humanitarian essence of the Jewish religion of history lies as the germ at the foundation of the social creations of the future. So long as the Jews failed to recognise this essence of the modern age, which from the beginning was their own essence, they were swept along involuntarily by the current of modern history. No rationalistic reform was needed for this, as those coun-