Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
7printed page
scan 21 of 434

7

to counterpose Bible and Talmud passages for and against Zionism. Aficionados may find such Pilpul entertaining. I cannot attribute any factual value to it.

But Dr. Güdemann not only combats the idea of establishing a Zionist empire, he also denies that the Jews are a people. Only out of “indignation and defiance” do they now feel themselves a special people in the face of their antisemitic persecutors. And what if it were so? A phenomenon is not thereby erased from reality just because one discovers its causes! On the contrary, establishing its causes is an acknowledgment of the phenomenon. Indignation and defiance are good feelings. I pity the weakling who is incapable of them. They are a healthy reaction to provocation and malice. The vitality of an organism is measured by the strength of its reactions to hostile stimuli. Defiance and indignation are rooted in self-respect, in a sense of honor, in a consciousness of strength. These are three sufficient sources of national sentiment.

The Jews are supposed to be not a people? To treat this point thoroughly, one would have to exhaust the whole of anthropology and the philosophy of history and unroll the immeasurable questions of the origin and nature of races, of the characteristics and foundations of nationality. I will refrain from that here, as I can reach the goal by a shorter path.

Dr. Güdemann asserts that the Jews are not a people. Well then: let him go to an antisemitic assembly in Berlin, let him step out onto the streets of Vienna when the white carnations have taken possession of them; then he will see if the antisemites will hesitate even for a moment to see in him the representative of a very par-