Ignaz Zollschan · The Racial Problem · 1912
182printed page
scan 234 of 568

Section 3 A Critique of the Historical Evidentiary Material for Racial Theories We cannot close our eyes to the daily observation that some races differ from one another quite tremendously, intellectually and psychically.

To explain this inequality, two theories have been invoked: the environment theory and the theory of the specificity of racial psyches. The environment theory was famously established by Buckle. It sees the ultimate cause for the different character of individual peoples in the difference of the surrounding external conditions. What the content of the other theory is, we have already explained in detail and will soon return to it again.

Regarding the effect of external conditions, no one can doubt that desert and river land, tropics and polar regions, mountains and valleys, soil conditions, climate, fauna and flora exert a tremendous influence on the development of technology and economy. But the matter is not such that the economic stage of the individual races is a passive copy of the geographical environment. There are countless examples in history where different peoples have successively inhabited one and the same country and yet have appeared in history in completely different ways. One of the most interesting of these examples is Spain. First it was inhabited by the Iberians; from this time we know little more than the name. Then came the Carthaginians; the country flourished. Later the