Ignaz Zollschan · The Racial Problem · 1912
170printed page
scan 222 of 568

170 The ancient writers know little to report of extraordinary loyalty among the Germanic peoples; what they do communicate corresponds entirely to the conditions of all barbarians, whose honesty in peaceful dealings and towards fellow tribesmen has been noted countless times by ancients and moderns. One will hardly find a people of nature not yet corrupted by civilization in whose character description these traits do not appear.

The fable of Germanic loyalty as a racial trait arose from a misunderstanding. One knows of the institution of the "retinues," for which a war hero and a number of followers bound themselves through mutual aid and loyalty. The lord granted leadership, sustenance, equipment, and spoils; the followers, their valiant arm. In a time when every social bond was absent, when justice could only be obtained through feuds, and the weak had no rights whatsoever against the strong, this institution was absolutely necessary, and its bond of loyalty was sanctified by the highest social need. This loyalty was founded on mutual and general benefit. The error was in the assumption that this was an exclusively Germanic phenomenon, which was by no means the case.

The passage from Tacitus is also cited again and again: "He who, surviving his lord, retreats from the line of battle is considered dishonorable and disgraceful for his entire life."

We find the same trait among many other peoples. If the Kaffir chieftain falls in battle, his bodyguard falls with him. Among the Iberians of Spain, the custom also prevailed that the retinue died with the chieftain. When Saul is defeated in the fight against the Philistines, he asks his armor-bearer to kill him, so that no uncircumcised person might do it. But as the latter refuses, he throws himself onto his own sword. Immediately, his armor-bearer follows the example of his lord; all the other men also fall with him.

Chinese history contains many features of sacrificial loyalty; here, too, the entourage falls by its own hand upon the death of the lord. In general, the custom that Caesar found among the Gauls, that upon the death of a lord his faithful followers are sacrificed or kill themselves, is exceedingly common.